LA ESQUINA CALIENTE (THE HOT CORNER) - A STUDY OF PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY IN ACTION AROUND THE WORLD

PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY vs REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY

We as citizens of the United States observe politics from afar and the vast majority of us may participate in the political process only to the extent that we go to the polls once a year to vote. We may endeavor to follow the news accounts of our nation's politics as they unfold, and of the consequences those political actions yield, but we have little power to influence our "democratically" elected officials. Perhaps we write an occasional letter to our senator or representative, but we almost inevitably receive a vague and impersonal response explaining why they will vote in our opposition.

Over the decades, our representative democracy has been systematically undermined and has ultimately failed in preserving the well being of the people of this nation. The system that the founding fathers painstakingly devised in order to best serve the interests and the will of the people has been corrupted and the systems of checks and balances on power that they instituted have been stripped away. Most of us accept this reality as being beyond our control and continue to observe, comment, and complain without aspiring to achieving any real change, without any hope of instituting a new system of governance that would instead take directly into account your views, and the views of your neighbors, and would empower you to make real positive change possible in your communities.

This site will attempt to explore in depth the places in the world where people are successfully bringing about that type of change in the face of similar odds, where an alternate form of democracy, which is called participatory or direct democracy, is taking root. Initiative, referendum & recall, community councils, and grassroots organizing are but a few ways in which direct/participatory democracy is achieving great success around the world.

Our system of representative democracy does not admit the voice of the people into congressional halls, the high courts, or the oval office where our rights and our liberties are being sold out from underneath us. Our local leaders and activists in our communities, and even those local elected officials who may have the best of intentions are for the most part powerless to make real positive change happen in our neighborhoods, towns and villages when there is so much corruption from above.

In places like Venezuela, Argentina, Bolivia, Nicaragua, Ecuador, Brazil, South Africa, India, and the Phillipines, new experiments in grass roots community based governance are taking place. There is much to be learned from these and other examples of participatory democracy from around the world when we try to examine how this grass-roots based governance could begin to take root here in our own country in order to alter our political system so that it might better serve the American people.

In the hope that one day we can become a nation working together as a united people practicing true democracy as true equals, we open this forum…

LATEST ENTRIES:

Friday, November 14, 2008

Participatory Democracy for Social and Ecological Justice


Sharing insights on a range of issues

BEIJING EXPRESS
By CELESTE FONG


Source:
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/10/26/focus/2379810&sec=focus

PRIOR to the meeting of Asian and European leaders in the Chinese capital for the Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) on Oct 24 and 25, more than 500 people from key grassroots, activist networks, and non-governmental organisations from Asia and Europe gathered at a three-day forum themed “For Social and Ecological Justice” here.

Since 1996, the Asia-Europe People’s Forum (AEPF) has been held every two years, normally before the ASEM, and AEPF participants gather to discuss a range of issues, exchange views and share insights.

For the Seventh Asia-Europe People’s Forum, the discussions were organised in three clusters: peace and security; social and economic rights and environmental justice; and participatory democracy and human rights.

With the onset of the current global financial crisis, the forum’s delegates called for a re-design of the global financial system, saying that Europe and Asia should take the initiative.

“So, once again we stand at a historical moment in a sombre mood, surveying the wreckage of crises that are both long-term and of immediate consequence; of crises that are both structural and conjunctural; of crises that demand not cosmetic reforms but a deep-rooted and sustainable transformation of how we shape the global order,’’ said Klang Parliamentarian Charles Santiago, one of the speakers at the forum’s opening ceremony.


Santiago: ‘Developing countries like China, India and Brazil could lead the world in re-setting a new financial rchitecture.’ — By Celeste Fong
Santiago, who is also director of Monitoring Sustainability of Globalisation, called for ASEM leaders to tell the global community from Europe and Asia that the unfettered deregulation of markets has to stop!

“Developing countries like China, India and Brazil could lead the world in re-setting a new financial architecture,” he added.

In his speech, he said govern ments, regional organisations, and international institutions like the IMF and World Bank have “all scrambled in unseemly haste to bail out their benefactors through subsidies for the rich.

“How ironic that the ‘free markets’ are today totally dependent on state intervention.

“The capitalist state is fulfilling its historic task of providing all the necessary guarantees for the survival of property.”

What is peculiar about the 2008 financial crisis, said Santiago, is that it is taking place alongside a food, energy and ecological crisis.

“It humbled the world’s economic super powers. They are asking developing countries like China to help solve the credit crisis through coordinated interest rate cuts,” he said.

China’s recent move to cut interest rates twice in three weeks is widely seen as part of a global collaboration to counter the crisis and an important contribution to the rest of the world.

Heidi Hautala, an experienced Green politician and a member of the Finnish Parliament, told the forum that the whole world is now feeling the consequences of an unprecedented collapse of the financial system.

“AEPF has consequently promoted the replacement of blind pro-market policies by alternative people-centred policies,” she said.

“We noted in Helsinki that ASEM countries control over half of the world’s gross national product. Thus, ASEM could be a key mechanism to lead the world on a sustainable path.

“To us, it is very clear that ASEM can only succeed if civil society gets access to it.’’

At the opening ceremony, Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi voiced his hope that the forum would play a positive role in promoting people-to-people exchanges and cooperation between Asia and Europe and in pushing forward the ASEM process.

“It (the forum) will also make a unique contribution to maintaining world peace, stability and prosperity and promoting human progress and development,’’ he said.

Yang said the recent turbulence in the international financial market has dealt a blow to the world economy and aroused the concern of the entire international community.

“No country in the world can expect to stay away from such issues as global warming, environmental degradation, resource shortage and the increasingly grave international economic and financial situation or address them on one’s own.”

After the three-day discussions, the AEPF called for a fresh policy agenda to address economic policies which take into consideration ordinary people, human rights and the environment.

The AEPF’s final declaration, including the call for a broadened agenda like governance and human rights issues, environmental sustainability and people-centred development, would be passed to the ASEM meeting which began on Friday.

Besides Santiago, who is also a member of the international organising committee of the AEPF, other Malaysian participants included Monash University School of Arts and Sciences lecturer Wong Chin Huat, PAS’ Capt Muhd Alimin Aziz, MBPJ councillor S. Ramakrishnan and other representatives from Malaysian NGOs.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

SOUTH KOREA: Building Organizations for Participatory Society


Civic groups unite to address broad range of social issues

movement that grew out of the candlelight protests responds to the ‘crisis in democracy and the people’s welfare’

Source:
http://english.hani.co.kr/arti/english_edition/e_national/315196.html

» Representatives of civic organizations and opposition parties discuss the formation of a new organization to address political and social issues at the People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy on October 9.
A solidarity organization representing the country’s progressives is being formed to carry on “the candlelight spirit.”
Representatives of civic and social movement groups like the People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy and Jinbo Corea, the umbrella union Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU, Minju Nochong), and the Democratic, Democratic Labor and New Progressive parties gathered at PSPD for an “emergency meeting” to agree on the formation of what will tentatively be called the “New Solidarity Organization for Democracy and the People’s Welfare” (Minminyeon). Organizers say they will officially kick-off preparations for the umbrella group on October 25 with the formation of a preparatory committee.

“Democracy and the people’s welfare have been in complete crisis since the start of the administration of President Lee Myung-bak,” said organizers at a press conference. “Laborers, farmers, netizens, intellectuals and political parties will come together to overcome this crisis with the New Solidarity Organization.”

Explaining the decision to include political parties, organizers, said it was made “in respect to the principle that we are going to seek very wide-ranging solidarity” and that parties might be included as having “observer” or other status.

The process that has led to the formation of Minminyeon runs parallel to the candlelight protests and the way the politics surrounding them dominated the political landscape.

“The ‘candlelight,’ that symbol of democracy, fell into difficulty when crushed by the Lee administration,” said Kim Min-yeong, PSPD’s secretary general. “Discussion about forming a solidarity organization originated in a sense of crisis, one that saw the crisis in democracy as directly related to the disastrous state of the people’s welfare.”

Civil society “elders” Paek Nak-chung, professor emeritus at Seoul National University, Park Won-soon of the Hope Institute and others met on September 24 and proposed a “consultative body that is organized with groups involved in a wide range of social movements.” The resulting organization was going to be a gathering of civil society groups that have felt the need for something like Minminyeon, Internet activists who were behind much of what became the candlelight protests, and a wide ranging scope of progressive political elements.

Part of the impetus for Minminyeon is the realization that there were going to be limits to what the People’s Countermeasure Council against Mad Cow Disease could do as an organization over the long term.

“We kept saying to ourselves that we needed an organization that could respond to the crisis in democracy and the people’s welfare, one that was more encompassing and went beyond the task force,” said Park Won-seok, the head of the task force’s “situation room.”

“We came to agree that we needed to be inclusive of all forces that share a consensus, including the labor movement and netizens,” said Park, adding that Minminyeon was the “broadest form of solidarity.”

Representatives of the groups present for the preparatory meeting adopted a declaration at the same “emergency meeting” October 9. “Each organization participating will respect each other’s diversity and act in solidarity where common responses are required,” it said.

“It was decided that we work with political parties because we are confident civil society forces have a leading role to play,” said Park Won-seok. “We believe that we can bring about change in the political situation as a whole, in the local government and National Assembly elections coming in 2010 and on to the presidential election, through solidarity and a loosely organized network.”

Whether Minminyeon will be able to overcome the differences among the groups that were part of the task force on mad cow disease remains to be seen. Minminyeon already encompasses a diverse range of groups and approaches, from those that want to adopt an“anti-dictatorship stance” to those that insist on an “loosely organized network.” Organizers say the differences will be overcome with the principle that issues will be decided “from the bottom up.”

“We have to organize quickly so that we can move together and decide how intense we are going to be, since the welfare crisis is so serious,” said one organizer.

Please direct questions or comments to [englishhani@hani.co.kr]

ITALIA: No Dal Molin - Vicenza

NO DAL MOLIN ALLE COOP: NON COSTRUITE UNA BASE DA GUERRA

lunedì 27 Ottobre 2008 (01h03) :
Fonte:
http://bellaciao.org/it/spip.php?article21631

La Coperativa Costruttori Cementisti e quella dei Muratori Cementisti hanno vinto l’appalto per costruire la base: 150 vicentini in delegazione alla Conferenza nazionale delle Coop per dire ai soci: state con noi. Il testo dell’appello in allegato all’articolo

Di Mariano Trevisan, Prc di Vicenza e movimento no dal Molin Dopo il successo della consultazione popolare, dove in una sola giornata ben 24.000 cittadini di Vicenza si sono espressi contro la costruzione della nuova base USA al Dal Molin, il movimento si rimette in marcia con tutta la forza che lo ha contraddistinto per più di due anni. Una serie di iniziative pressoché giornaliere che dureranno un mese e che avranno il loro apice con la programmazione di uno sciopero generale della città di Vicenza.

Come prima iniziativa il popolo delle “pignatte” oggi 25 ottobre è andato a fare “visita” alla Conferenza Nazionale delle Coop. tenutasi nella città di Parma, dove centinaia di soci coop provenienti da tutta Italia erano presenti. Tema del convegno “Rapporto fra struttura, etica e dimensione”, perché da tempo queste organizzazioni sono diventate sempre più industrie e sempre meno cooperative.

Molti si chiederanno quali sono le motivazioni che ci hanno spinti ad andare a questo congresso, lo scopo è presto detto: la Coperativa C.C.C. (Coperativa costruttori cementisti) e la C.M.C. (Coperativa muratori cementisti) sono le due ditte che hanno vinto l’appalto per costruire la nuova Base a Vicenza. Allora quale motivo migliore se non andare a Parma per cercare di toccare le corde sensibili dei soci Coop? Questi soci dovrebbero essere la parte più attenta alle tematiche di guerra e alle basi militari straniere.

Alle sei del mattino, una delegazione di 150 persone in rappresentanza dei 24.000 vicentini contrari alla base, con 3 pullman si sono recati al convegno suddetto, con bandiere, striscioni, volantini e video sull’area del Dal Molin. Abbiamo parlato con moltissimi soci Coop. che si sono mostrati attenti alle nostre proposte e moralmente scossi di come anche le Coop. quando si tratta di fare denari mettano in un angolo l’etica e i suoi sani principi.

Siamo riusciti a concordare che tutti i 150 componenti del No Dal Molin entrassero al convegno e che uno di noi leggesse un comunicato affinché i tanti soci facciano pressione sulla C.C.C e sulla C.M.C. Lo stesso comunicato lo abbiamo inoltrato al gruppo Consigliare Regionale del PRC dell’Emilia Romagna dove il nostro partito è in maggioranza affinché sia messo ai voti e, se approvato anche il Consiglio Regionale dichiari la propria contrarietà a questo appalto e alla costruzione della nuova base USA al Dal Molin.

Ai falsi profeti che vanno dicendo che la nostra è una battaglia fatta contro i mulini a vento voglio solamente ricordare che: i lavori della Base dovevano partire secondo il Commissario Governativo Paolo Costa nel settembre 2006, ad ottobre 2008 la Ederle 2 non è ancora partita e vi posso garantire che non molleremo un millimetro, a furia di paletti, manifestazioni, ricorsi, blocchi stradali e consultazioni, siamo riusciti, noi, piccola armata brancaleone ad ostacolare i progetti della più grande nazione del mondo; gli Stati Uniti d’America.

Vicenza, 25 Ottobre 2008

Di : Vicenza
lunedì 27 Ottobre 2008

Tuesday, November 11, 2008

SPAIN: Participatory Budgeting Advances

New methodology to improve participatory democracy

nächste Meldung 07.11.2008
Source:
http://www.innovationsreport.de/html/berichte/informationstechnologie/methodology_improve_participatory_democracy_121862.html

Researchers from the Decision Analysis and Statistics Group within the Department of Artificial Intelligence at the Universidad Politécnica de Madrid’s School of Computing have developed a methodology for improving participatory democracy that could be ready for the Spain’s next local elections due to be held in 2011.

Over 240 Spanish municipalities had a go at participatory budgeting in 2004, and it is estimated that by 2010 citizens will be helping to decide how to allocate 10% of the municipal budget. Until now, though, these participatory budgeting experiences have been carried through without the software to gather citizens’ opinions in real time and then clearly display their preferences as charts on politicians’ computers.

Organizing opinion via the Internet

The School of Computing’s research group, composed of computer scientists, mathematicians and statisticians, has developed this methodology using new technologies, particularly the Internet, as support for organizing and optimizing citizen participation. The methodology is now two-thirds complete and could be applied on the scale of either a municipality or a whole country.

The aim of this methodology is to add citizens’ preferences to political decision-making processes. This it does by establishing a number of questions that citizens answer over the Internet. Duly converted to statistical values, these responses indicate citizens’ opinions on the decision to be taken by politicians in the shape of a chart. A code system prevents people not on the electoral roll from participating.

The methodology represents participants’ beliefs and preferences, evaluating the different budget alternatives based on Dempster and Shafer’s evidential reasoning and ranking the alternatives using a notion of distance from maximum and minimum utility.

Participatory Democracy

Participatory budgeting is shifting the idea of democracy from representation, where citizens’ preferences are taken into account at election time only, to direct participation and discussion. This is an attempt at giving citizens a say in the decision on how to spend part of their municipality’s budget.

The Decision Analysis and Statistics Research Group has collaborated and is now actively participating in several research projects focusing on the development of software tools targeting e-democracy and, especially, participatory budgeting.

They include TED: Towards Electronic Democracy, funded by the European Science Foundation (2003/06); eDemocracia: Apoyo a la Toma de Decisiones Complejas Basadas en Internet (e-Democracy: Internet-based Complex Decision-Making Support), funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (2004/07); Conceptos y Sistemas de Apoyo a la Democracia Electrónica (Electronic Democracy Concepts and Support Systems), funded through Madrid Regional Government’s IV PRICIT (2006/09); and Toma de Decisiones en Grupo con Imprecisión (Imprecise Group Decision Making), funded by the Ministry of Science and Innovation (2008/2011).

Monday, November 10, 2008

BRASIL: EUA: Democracia Participativa


EUA: Democracia Participativa

Os Estados Unidos promoveram cerca de 150 referendos locais, aproveitando o embalo das eleições gerais. E nós?

07 Nov 2008 - 00h15min

Fonte:
http://www.opovo.com.br/opovo/opiniao/833759.html#

A eleição de Barack Obama atraiu uma maior atenção do mundo para o sistema eleitoral americano. Apesar de falho em termos de organização e, por isso, vulnerável à fraude, o processo eleitoral americano é rico em termos de mecanismo de participação, na medida em que combina democracia indireta ou representativa, com democracia direta, proporcionando o que se convencionou chamar de democracia participativa.

Tirar lições do processo eleitoral americano é importante não apenas para se conferir a solidez dos fundamentos políticos que embasam essa nação - assim como as falhas merecedoras de correção em seu arcabouço institucional -, mas, sobretudo, como fator de inspiração para as democracias que vieram após a constituição dos Estados Unidos da América.

De uma forma geral, o Brasil tem muito a se inspirar no modelo institucional americano. É inegável que, do ponto de vista da sistemática eleitoral, o Brasil está bem a frente, seja pelo fato de a escolha de nossos governantes ser direta (com cada voto correspondendo a um eleitor ) seja por conta da própria sistemática de votação, usando tecnologia de ponta, através de urnas eletrônicas. Enquanto isso, nos EUA, alguns estados ainda utilizam os mesmos procedimentos do século XVIII e XIX.

No entanto, o fato de os americanos adotarem com freqüência consultas diretas ao cidadão, através de referendos sobre a realidade local, acoplados às eleições convencionais (seja para a destituição dos representantes (recall), seja para aprovar ou rejeitar propostas de lei, em nível local), sua superioridade é inegável, em relação ao sistema brasileiro.

Reconhecidamente, o sistema presidencialista tem uma forma institucional muito rígida, com mandatos fixos, e sem o instituto da responsabilização do Executivo por seus atos. De uma forma geral, um governante só pode ser destituído, nesse sistema, através de impeachment, no caso de ter cometido crime de responsabilidade. Por conta disso, surgiu a necessidade de introduzir mecanismos de monitoramento do poder pelos cidadãos, através da consulta direta (seja quando estão em jogo decisões polêmicas, seja quando há um impasse político, que possa descambar para o campo institucional). Daí porque os golpes de estado são mais freqüentes no presidencialismo (nos EUA se mata o governante).

Depois dos Estados Unidos, talvez só a Venezuela, a Bolívia e o Equador tenham instrumentos efetivos de democracia direta. A Constituição brasileira de 1988 preconiza esses instrumentos, mas nunca foram regulamentados e seu acionamento está a cargo dos políticos, que, compreensivelmente, não querem dividir poderes com o povo. Contudo, já é hora de mudar essa situação e seguir o exemplo americano e de países vizinhos que seguem uma tendência inevitável da democracia do século XXI, de tornar-se cada vez mais participativa.

MEXICO: Questioning the Efficacy of Institutions

Democracy Under Construction

Filed under:
Democratization, Latin America — Jason Lakin @ 12:58 pm
October 27, 2008
Source:
http://www.harvardir.org/blog/?p=331

In 2006, when supporters of Mexico’s Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO), then candidate for the leftist PRD, took to the streets to protest alleged vote fraud during the presidential elections, many carried banners that said “Democracy Under Construction.” The implication was clear: democracy at the institutional level, where elections were organized and votes counted, was not working. Real democracy was happening in the streets, where the people were organizing and raising their voices against these same institutions.

This “institutions versus the people” dichotomy in Mexican democracy is the most important legacy of the 2006 election. It continues to define the ideology of AMLO and his supporters up to the present. Last week, speaking about the energy reform which was approved by the Mexican Senate, AMLO said that what mattered was not what the legislature said, but what “we decide, the people.”

The logic is familiar to analysts that distinguish between republicanism (rule by democratic institutions, indirectly controlled by the people) and democracy (rule by the people directly). Though we most often use the term democracy in everyday discussions of regime type, what we usually mean is republicanism: rule by democratic institutions. No one believes that rule by institutions is a panacea. Advocates of direct democracy are correct to note that institutions frequently deviate from the will of the people, pursuing their own interests instead. On the other hand, advocates of republicanism presume, also correctly, that direct democracy is neither more realistic nor necessarily fairer than rule by institutions. Republicans point out that democratic publics are easily swayed by dangerous group-think, which, in the absence of institutions that force deliberation, can lead to the repression of minorities, and the prioritization of short-term gains over long-term development.

In general, the relevant question in a republic is whether or not republican institutions are legitimate. When institutions are legitimate, which minimally requires fair elections, then we tend to think that these institutions should be respected, even if we allow citizens to protest, file lawsuits, or lobby to change decisions made by them. What happens, however, when the institutions are not legitimate? This is the position taken by AMLO and his followers, who argued that the 2006 elections were illegitimate because the institutions that organized them were illegitimate, and because the process was not free and fair.

There is no question that AMLO’s attack on Mexican republican institutions is self-serving. However, whether AMLO is motivated by self-interest or not, many Mexicans do doubt the legitimacy and efficacy of their institutions. The only solution to widespread doubts about the legitimacy of institutions is the re-foundation of those institutions with renewed legitimacy, not, as Mexican conservatives sometimes seem to believe, to repeatedly restate that institutions are legitimate because they are institutions.

In fact, Mexico’s legislators are slowly achieving institutional renewal. The PAN (the president’s party) and the PRD were able to reach a consensus earlier this year to renew the leadership of the electoral institute (IFE), whose credibility was severely damaged in 2006. Although President Calderón was among the worst purveyors of the “institutions exist therefore they are legitimate” doctrine during the 2006 elections, he has pursued negotiation and consensus-building on key initiatives, such as fiscal and now energy policy. The result has been limited reform, but increasingly legitimate procedures for arriving at it.

The biggest threat to Mexico’s institutional renewal today comes from a different source: the spiraling corruption engendered by the war on drugs. Today, El Universal reports that officials working for SIEDO, a special government office dedicated to investigating organized crime, have been on retainer for the drug lords since at least 2004. These officials, who earned as much as US$450,000 per month, passed along government information to one of Mexico’s most notorious cartels, that of the Beltrán Leyva brothers. The revelations were the result of the government’s own Operation Cleanup, which means, of course, that they represent a double-edged sword. On the one hand, they should increase confidence that the government is functioning to police its own abuses. On the other, they reinforce the perception that the government is riddled with corruption, so much so that the war on drugs is doomed to failure.

Young democracies frequently struggle to renovate a large number of weak institutions all at once, but many do survive. The renovation of institutions is a tricky business, and there are plenty of reasons to worry that Mexico is not up to the task. But if there is one thing Mexicans proved during the twentieth century, it is that they are exceptionally creative at reinventing institutions. The one-party regime waxed and waned, but it survived intact for decades by adapting to radically changing international and domestic circumstances. Mexico’s leaders have demonstrated, since the crisis of confidence in 2006, a surprising ability to work together to avoid the worst. Many more surprises will be needed to push the country’s democratization forward. On this gloomy Monday, overshadowed by the disillusion of new corruption allegations, the country’s leadership may look down, but I wouldn’t count them out.

Sunday, November 9, 2008

BOLIVIA: Democracia Directa y Participativa en la Nueva Constitución


La CPE admite la democracia comunitaria para el gobierno

Fuente:
http://fmbolivia.com.bo/noticia5027-la-cpe-admite-la-democracia-comunitaria-para-el-gobierno.html

La Paz - Bolivia, 29 de octubre.- El proyecto de Constitución Política del Estado que será sometido a referendos aprobatorio y dirimente el 25 de enero incorpora a “la democracia comunitaria” en el sistema de Gobierno que podría tener Bolivia de aprobarse el documento constitucional.

La democracia proyectada por la nueva Carta Magna incluye las variables participativa, representativa y comunitaria. La aparición en el texto de este mecanismo es novedosa, ya que en el documento vigente sólo se reconocen el sistema democrático representativo y el directo.

Dentro del proyecto constitucional, el Capítulo Tercero, referido al Sistema de Gobierno, reconoce “normas y procedimientos propios de las naciones y pueblos indígena originario campesinos” a la hora de elegir autoridades, además incluye los cabildos y asambleas como formas deliberativas de la sociedad.

El diputado de Unidad Nacional (UN) Alejandro Colanzi, quien participó en la Mesa de Concertación que modificó el texto aprobado en 2007 en Oruro, sostuvo que este artículo “reconoce la diversidad de formas (democráticas) que aparecen en el país”.

La forma comunitaria que se incorpora a la democracia formal boliviana establece la elección de autoridades y representantes a través de procedimientos propios de las naciones y pueblos indígena originario campesinos. El proyecto además establece que la organización política, para todas las modalidades (representativa, participativa y comunitaria), será establecida mediante una ley.

Consultado acerca de la incorporación de la democracia comunitaria, Colanzi considera que ésta aparece en el texto gracias a las prácticas de la sociedad civil en los últimos años y que este sistema es un concepto que va más allá de las prácticas indígenas que “rescata el viejo concepto de la comuna”.

El politólogo Carlos Cordero considera que la democracia comunitaria es “una novedad en la tradición republicana, liberal y representativa”.

Empero, señala que falta observar cómo se articularán los distintos mecanismos democráticos y de qué manera éstos sostendrán sus relaciones con las formas de Gobierno reconocidas en la propuesta de Carta Magna.

En el capítulo de autonomías se determinaron, después de las negociaciones del Gobierno con los prefectos y los parlamentarios, cinco niveles gubernamentales: nacional, departamental, municipal, indígena y regional.

“En el tiempo se verá si se pueden complementar, ser armónicos o provocan tensionamientos”.

La faceta comunitaria de la democracia significa “la superación de la etapa donde las decisiones las tomaban técnicos con visión economicistas, como sucedió en las últimas dos décadas”, según el diputado Colanzi. En cambio, Cordero teme que el “asambleísmo pueda fortalecer los autoritarismos debido a las presiones ilícitas que se dan en esas situaciones”.

El texto propuesto reconoce como democracia participativa al referéndum, la iniciativa ciudadana, el revocatorio, las asambleas y los cabildos y la consulta previa.

“Las asambleas y cabildos tendrán carácter deliberativo”. La democracia participativa fue insertada en la Carta Magna que todavía está vigente en la gestión presidencial de Carlos Mesa (2003-2005).

Los principios del Estado

El artículo 8 del proyecto de Constitución Política del Estado (ver cuadro superior) incorpora como principios ético-morales del Estado boliviano los mandamientos propios de los pueblos indígenas originarios. Para el sociólogo Julio Mantilla, estos elementos no son añadiduras “folklóricas”, sino más bien “elaboraciones filosóficas” y visiones del desarrollo del “buen vivir”.

Para el especialista, el mencionado artículo incorpora visiones de la vida que son distintas de las planteadas por el racionalismo occidental. “La visión del suma qamaña, por ejemplo, es una visión de equilibrio entre trabajo, conocimiento, placer y solidaridad”. Mantilla considera que la irrupción de estos planteamientos representa un cambio muy profundo en nuestra manera de entender el mundo. “Se trata de cómo nosotros interiorizamos la nueva filosofía”.

Este precepto “es un tema central”. “Éste es un proceso gradual que en los próximos 20 años vamos a seguir madurando. Afectará tremendamente en la cotidianidad”.

El sociólogo comentó que estas “dimensiones filosóficas, lastimosamente, no son explicadas y por eso son vulgarizadas como algo folklórico”, y concluyó que esta incorporación es un avance “postmoderno” en la nueva Constitución.

El sistema de gobierno

La nueva CPE

Artículo11:

I. La República de Bolivia adopta para su gobierno la forma democrática participativa, representativa y comunitaria, con equivalencia de condiciones entre hombres y mujeres.

II. La democracia se ejerce de las siguientes formas, que serán desarrolladas por la ley:

1. Directa y participativa, por medio del referendo, la iniciativa legislativa ciudadana, la revocatoria de mandato, la asamblea, el cabildo y la consulta previa. Las asambleas y cabildos tendrán carácter deliberativo conforme a ley.

2. Representativa, por medio de la elección de representantes por voto universal, directo y secreto, conforme a ley.

3. Comunitaria, por medio de la elección, designación o nominación de autoridades y representantes por normas y procedimientos propios de las naciones y pueblos indígena originario campesinos, entre otros, conforme a ley.

Artículo 12:

I. El Estado se organiza y estructura su poder público a través de los órganos Legislativo, Ejecutivo, Judicial y Electoral. La organización está fundamentada en la independencia…

La CPE vigente

La Constitución Política del Estado que está vigente hace mención al sistema de Gobierno en los primeros preceptos del documento.

Artículo1:

I. Bolivia, libre, independiente, soberana, multiétnica y pluricultural constituida en República unitaria, adopta para su gobierno la forma democrática representativa y participativa, fundada en la unión y la solidaridad de todos los bolivianos.

Artículo 4:

El pueblo delibera y gobierna por medio de sus representantes y mediante la Asamblea Constituyente, la iniciativa legislativa ciudadana y el referéndum, establecidos por esta Constitución y normados por ley.

Artículo 2:

La soberanía reside en el pueblo; es inalienable e imprescriptible; su ejercicio está delegado a los poderes Legislativo, Ejecutivo y Judicial. La independencia y coordinación de estos poderes es la base del gobierno. Las funciones del poder público: legislativa, ejecutiva y judicial, no pueden ser reunidas en el mismo órgano.

Principios del Estado

La nueva CPE

Artículo 8:

I. El Estado asume y promueve como principios ético-morales de la sociedad plural: ama qhilla, ama llulla, ama suwa (no seas flojo, no seas mentiroso ni seas ladrón), suma qamaña (vivir bien), ñandereko (vida armoniosa), teko kavi (vida buena), ivi maraei (tierra sin mal) y qhapaj ñan (camino o vida noble).

II. El Estado se sustenta en los valores de unidad, igualdad, inclusión, dignidad, libertad, solidaridad, reciprocidad, respeto, complementariedad, armonía, transparencia, equilibrio, igualdad de oportunidades, equidad social y de género en la participación, bienestar común, responsabilidad, justicia social, distribución y redistribución de los productos y bienes sociales, para vivir bien.

Artículo 9:

Son fines y funciones esenciales del Estado, además de los que establece la Constitución y la ley:
1. Constituir una sociedad justa y armoniosa, cimentada en la descolonización, sin discriminación ni explotación.

La CPE vigente

Los principios, en la Carta Magna que está en vigencia, se mencionan en el artículo 8, que señala:
Artículo 8:

Es un Estado Social y Democrático de Derecho que sostiene como valores superiores de su ordenamiento jurídico, la libertad, la igualdad y la justicia.

Artículo 30:

Los poderes públicos no podrán delegar las facultades que les confiere esta Constitución, ni atribuir al Poder Ejecutivo otras que las que expresamente les están acordadas por ella.

Artículo 31:

Son nulos los actos de los que usurpen funciones que no les competen, así como los actos de los que ejerzan jurisdicción o potestad que no emane de la ley.

Artículo 32:

Nadie será obligado a hacer lo que la Constitución y las leyes no manden, ni privarse de lo que ellas no prohíban.

Artículo 34:

Los que vulneren derechos y garantías constitucionales quedan sujetos a la jurisdicción ordinaria.

Hitos Democráticos

El referéndum por los hidrocarburos inauguró la etapa de la democracia participativa.

La elección de prefectos, en 2005, dio inicio a otra faceta de la vida democrática.

La consulta revocatoria del 10 de agosto marcó el colofón de la participación.

PHILIPPINES: Looking to U.S. Direct Democracy as Example


This interesting piece from the Philippines looks to the direct democracy of initiative & referendum at the state level in the United States as an example for the Philippines to follow. - Editor

Direct Democracy

Pinoy Kasi

By Michael Tan
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 02:06:00 11/05/2008

Source: http://opinion.inquirer.net/inquireropinion/columns/view/20081105-170283/Direct-democracy

The media frenzy around the US elections has mainly focused on the presidential race, and for good reason, considering the role American presidents play in charting the world’s future. This election is also particularly significant because we just might see the first African-American president.

But I’ve followed the elections also because they show how democracies work. Beneath the glitter and glamour, presidential elections allow substantive discussions of issues that matter to Americans, and to the world.

Few people are aware of another important part of American elections, that of referendums which allow citizens in some states to make some very vital decisions. In the Philippines, we also have this system of citizens’ initiatives but it hasn’t worked out, so maybe we should look more closely at what goes on in the US.

Burning issues

The issues taken up in these referendums reflect the burning issues of the day for Americans. This year, the most hotly debated propositions to be voted on revolve around abortion and same-sex marriage but there are initiatives around taxes, education, animal welfare and energy. California, for example, has two initiatives around alternative energy, including one that requires utilities companies to generate 20 percent of its power from renewable energy by 2010, 40 percent by 2020 and 50 percent by 2025.

The propositions also reflect how liberal or conservative a particular state might be. For example, 26 states have passed DOMASes or “Defense of Marriage Amendments,” which define marriage as a union of a man and a woman. These amendments are intended to block same-sex marriage, which is currently allowed in three states: California, Connecticut and Massachusetts. In this year’s elections, three states—Arizona, California and Florida—will be voting on a DOMAS (note that California already allows same-sex marriage so their new initiative is intended to overthrow that law).

Abortion has been legal in the US since 1973 but individual states have been looking for ways to impose restrictions. This year, there are three states with abortion-related initiatives. Colorado has a “Defense of the Person Initiative” which would bestow personhood status from the moment of fertilization, giving the fetus “equal rights of life, liberty and property.” If passed, this act would make abortion a crime equivalent to murder and homicide. South Dakota will vote on a constitutional amendment that will ban all abortions except for rape, incest or to protect women’s health. California has a proposition that will require parents of a minor to be notified, with a 48-hour waiting period, after that notification, before the minor can have her abortion.

It’s a powerful system of direct democracy—direct in the sense that citizens themselves make very important decisions, rather than leaving it to elected officials and legislators. At present, 18 states allow citizens to exercise direct democracy to amend a state constitutions, 22 allow citizens to initiate new laws or statutes and in 25 states, citizens can even overthrow or veto a state statute that has already been passed.

The process usually begins with citizens themselves gathering signatures for a petition to put an issue to a vote. The rules vary from one state to another, requiring a certain number for the petition to finally make it to the ballot. For example, California, for a proposition to revise a law, the number of signatures required to put it to a vote is equivalent to 5 percent of the total votes cast in the last election for the governor. To amend the constitution, the requirement is 8 percent.

Not all these initiatives begin with citizens. Some states have a system where the legislators themselves refer an issue to the public for approval.

It’s not easy to get these propositions to the point of a referendum. Gathering petitions is tedious work, and can be challenged by other citizens’ groups. Law suits have been filed against some of these propositions, effectively stopping them from being voted on.

If the propositions are eligible for a vote, the office of the secretary of the state has to put together materials to help citizens make an informed decision. Information materials (in print, and lately, even in audio for those who are visually impaired) are disseminated, explaining the pros and cons involved. This includes a discussion of the issue itself, but can go on to an extended examination of other implications, for example, the cost of enforcing the new law or lost income in terms of taxes. The materials also list people, groups, even newspapers that have endorsed or opposed the initiative. The main sponsors of the initiative are also put under scrutiny for possible vested interests.

Animal rights

There are many other initiatives that are going to be voted on in this election. As an educator, I was intrigued by Oregon’s Measure 60 where teachers’ classroom performance would determine pay raises.

Massachusetts has a Sensible Marijuana Policy Initiative, which would decriminalize small amounts (less than one ounce) of marijuana. Proponents say this would save $130 million a year in court and imprisonment costs, but those opposed, organized as a Coalition for Safe Streets, say such decriminalization would send a wrong message to young people.

Animal rights have become a big issue in the US and are reflected this year by three initiatives. California has Proposition 2, which requires that “calves raised for veal, egg-laying hens and pregnant pigs be confined only in ways that allow these animals to lie down, stand up, fully extend their limbs and turn around freely.” Massachusetts has an initiative that would ban the racing of dogs, specifically greyhounds.

Then there’s Alaska’s Wolf and Bear Protection Act, which went up for a vote a few weeks ago, during the primary elections, and was defeated. This was a referral, sent by state legislators to the public, which would have prohibited “shooting of free-ranging wolf, wolverine or grizzly bear on the same day a person has been airborne.” The law was proposed because hunters have been using aircraft to spot the animals before going after them.

The Philippines has Republic Act 6735, which allows these citizens’ initiatives, but we’ve seen it used repeatedly, from Con-con to Con-ass, by politicians looking for ways to amend the Constitution so they can stay in power. The Action for Economic Reform website has a good, brief critique of the law as “defective legislation,” making the propositions “easy to initiate, difficult to pass.” The problem is informed choice: being able to get enough information and education materials out to voters, rather than letting them be manipulated by politicians.

ITALIA: Democrazia Diretta en Bolzano - Livro di Thomas Benedikter


Livro: Democrazia Diretta - di Thomas Benedikter
Thomas Benedikter democrazia diretta











A Ferrara:

Notizia inserita il 6/11/2008

Presentazione del libro Thomas Benedikter

Pbc parla di democrazia diretta

Questa sera, alle ore 21, nella sala riunioni dell'associazione Per il Bene Comune, in piazzale Stazione 15, verrà presentato il libro “Democrazia diretta: più potere ai cittadini”, di Thomas Benedikter. Con l'autore parteciperanno Cinzia Bottene del comitato vicentino No Dal Molin; Giuseppe Carpentieri di Cittadinanza Attiva, Andrea Palamara di Per il Bene Comune.

“Durante la serata – spiega Monia Benini, presidente di Per il Bene Comune - tutti gli interventi saranno trasmessi in diretta via internet sul canale www.mogulus.com/perilbenecomune e i cittadini presenti in sala o collegati avranno la possibilità, anche attraverso la valutazione di esperienze internazionali, di discutere e confrontarsi sulla via d'uscita dalla limitazione della democrazia diretta e della partecipazione popolare a cui ci hanno portato gli attuali partiti italiani”.

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

NIGERIA: Demanding Direct Democracy



The business of democracy in Nigeria

By Joshua Ocheja
Source: http://www.tribune.com.ng/06102008/opinion.html

Democracy is the government of the people, by the people and for the people. It is basically of two types: Representative Democracy and Direct Democracy. Representative democracy is one founded on the principle of the people’s representatives, the representatives form more than one independent ruling body, vested with the responsibility of acting in the people’s interest but not as their proxy representatives, but with enough authority to take initiatives in the face of challenging circumstances.

Direct democracy, classically termed pure democracy, comprises a form of democracy and theory of civics wherein sovereignty is lodged in the assembly of all citizens who choose to participate. Depending on the particular system, this assembly might pass executive motions, make laws, elect and dismiss officials and conduct trials. Where the assembly elects officials, these are executive agents or direct representatives, bound to the will of the people.

Direct democracy stands in contrast to representative democracy, where sovereignty is exercised by a subset of people, usually on the basis of election. However, it is possible to combine the two into representative direct democracy.

In Nigeria today, we have striven for democracy for the greater part of our political history. Democracy is not a political buzzword but something definite, something we have relentlessly striven to attain, especially during the 29 years of military rule.

Those years were marred by the brazen ambitions of the military junta who were determined in retaining their leadership of the nation with detrimental repercussions. The contemporary Nigerian society consists of over 250 ethno-linguistic groups and is among the most ethnically-diverse countries in the world. The challenge our nascent democracy faces, is not the health status of the president or the number of ethnic groups, but the sheer politicisation and incorporation of ethnic diversity into national life.

Each ethnic group under the cover of relevance organises itself in the contest for national booties and view public policies largely from the prism of their sectional interest. Ethnic sentiments is at the heart of the perennial allegations of marginalisation by the different ethnic groups that make up the Nigerian nation

Democracy in Nigeria is a limited liability company where certain people have ownership and these people are conformist in that they feel Nigeria is not ripe to be listed on the stock exchange so the citizens can have shares via public offer.

The big question is how democratic is Nigeria? Nigeria is 48 years old. This is a company that has been in business for that long and remains a limited liability company whereas other nations that have not clocked 48 have become full fledged public liability companies, posting impressive financial result and giving its share holders(citizens) a reason to smile. But the Nigerian scenario is a different one. When an organisation stands as a limited liability company, their profit goes to the pocket of the few that are the owners. This is what our beloved country has become! You might want to agree with me that there exists a powerful cabal that dictates our yesterday, today and tomorrow.

These people have hypnotised us and they too have been hypnotised by their imagination. Their greatest worry is, when the spell eventually fades away what befalls them? Nigeria can not remain a limited liability company anymore; it has outgrown that status. Its citizens have a right to know who gets what, when and how.

The year 1999 marked a defining moment for Nigeria, I remember vividly when Obasanjo was being sworn in as president. He wore a facial expression, which I could not interprete. If only I could read his thought pattern. It was not easy but it was worth it, I believe Obasanjo will be telling his close aides in Ota farm. The task of ruling Nigeria is the most tedious in human endeavour. Aside the paraphernalia of office that are enticing, the rest is in the hands of God. You are for God or for the devil.

When Moses went to Pharaoh to deliver the heavenly message, Pharaoh in his earthly wisdom, dismissed it with a wave of the hand. The rest is history. This same scenario is playing out in Nigeria: Let us go, we keep saying! The ruling cabal is turning the deaf ear to our pleas. Nigeria is 48 and sincerely, we cannot tell our right from the left.

But I have a dream: that one day, we shall be free and free indeed! Nigeria will become a public liability company, churning out impressive result for its shareholders (citizens).

Friday, October 31, 2008

ESPAÑA: EB Insta a Impulsar una Ley de Participación en Bilbao


EB insta a impulsar una Ley de Participación y propone una campaña para desmontar "tergiversaciones" sobre la consulta

Dice que la sociedad debe poder "decidir su futuro en sentido amplio" y pide al nacionalismo que asuma "este reto" para resultar "creíble"

BILBAO, 28 Sep. (EUROPA PRESS) -
Fuente:
http://www.europapress.es/nacional/noticia-eb-insta-impulsar-ley-participacion-propone-campana-desmontar-tergiversaciones-consulta-20080928114249.html

Ezker Batua-Berdeak instó hoy al resto de partidos a apostar, en sus programas electorales, por la aprobación de una Ley de Participación Ciudadana en la próxima legislatura. Asimismo, propuso la puesta en marcha de una campaña informativa que "contribuya a desmontar las tergiversaciones urdidas" por PSOE y PP en relación a la Ley de Consulta, y acusó a ambas formaciones de "presentar como verdades lo que son burdas mentiras".

En un acto con cargos públicos y militantes de la formación en Bilbao, su coordinador general, Javier Madrazo, hizo público un manifiesto, denominado 'Participar es tu derecho', dentro de la campaña a favor del impulso de la participación ciudadana que desarrollará durante las próximas semanas y que tiene como uno de sus ejes principales la promoción de una Ley de Participación Ciudadana.

En este documento, que consta de diez puntos, EB reitera su compromiso "inequívoco" con la participación ciudadana como "un ejercicio de profundización democrática". En este sentido, reivindica que, en una "democracia real", la ciudadanía debe ser "agente activo y protagonista" en los ámbitos políticos, económicos, sociales, culturales y de género.

En esta línea, insiste en que la convocatoria de "una consulta no vinculante para exigir a ETA el cese por y para siempre de la violencia, y reivindicar el inicio de un diálogo democrático sin exclusiones" constituye "un derecho legítimo" de la sociedad vasca.

En este sentido, afirma que, aunque acata la sentencia del Tribunal Constitucional sobre la Ley vasca de Consulta que "impide en la práctica llevar a cabo esta iniciativa", no comparte sus argumentos, que "obedecen a razones exclusivamente políticas y no tienen un fundamento jurídico sólido".

A su entender, "estamos ante una campaña política, jurídica y mediática que manipula y distorsiona el significado real de la consulta no vinculante" aprobada por el Parlamento vasco. De este modo, subrayó que "una consulta no vinculante no es un referéndum" y que esta iniciativa no es "rupturista, ni soberanista y mucho menos independentista" ya que, de lo contrario, EB "nunca la hubiera apoyado".

La formación que dirige Javier Madrazo denuncia "la hipocresía y el cinismo del Gobierno Zapatero y el PSOE", teniendo en cuenta que "en Cataluña y en Andalucía reconocen la competencia de las instituciones de ambas comunidades para convocar consultas populares, mientras que en Euskadi niegan este mismo derecho, reconocido en el artículo 9.2 del Estatuto de Autonomía de Gernika".

Asimismo, considera que, en el actual contexto de "recrudecimiento de la actividad terrorista" se hace "aún más necesario dar la voz" a la ciudadanía vasca para pedir a ETA su disolución "por y para siempre, y sin condiciones".

"¿Cabe mayor deslegitimación de la violencia, de quienes la practican y de quienes callan ante ella que ser conscientes en primera persona del rechazo que generan en la sociedad? ¿Por qué el Gobierno Zapatero y el PSOE pueden negociar con ETA, con atentados y sin ellos, y la ciudadanía, en cambio, no puede mostrarles su condena en una consulta no vinculante?", cuestiona.

Ante esta situación, Ezker Batua-Berdeak reivindica el derecho de la sociedad vasca a "plantar cara" a ETA en "todos los ámbitos de la vida pública". Según añade, "ha llegado el momento de expresar nuestro hartazgo ante la violencia y nuestro compromiso inequívoco con los derechos humanos de un modo rotundo".

ETA tiene que ser "plenamente consciente de que no representa a nadie y su única salida es su propia desaparición", afirma EB, que se muestra convencida de que, "si se celebrase una consulta no vinculante en este sentido, incluso la llamada izquierda abertzale mayoritariamente diría no a la violencia y sí al diálogo".

MODELO PROPIO

El manifiesto recoge además la apuesta por un modelo de democracia participativa "propio y diferenciado" que tome en consideración "la voluntad de la ciudadanía no sólo en el ámbito de la pacificación y la normalización política, sino en el conjunto de la actividad pública". En este sentido, insta a PNV, PSOE, PP, Eusko Alkartasuna y Aralar a incorporar a sus programas electorales una declaración expresa a favor de la aprobación de una Ley de Participación Ciudadana en la próxima legislatura que "regule y establezca mecanismos de democracia directa".

Ezker Batua-Berdeak censura "las posiciones de quienes hacen bandera de la consulta no vinculante, pero después se oponen a iniciativas igualmente legítimas y democráticas como son conocer la opinión de la ciudadanía en relación con debates tan relevantes para nuestro futuro como el trazado del tren de alta velocidad, la instalación de incineradoras y centrales térmicas en nuestros pueblos y ciudades, o bien el desarrollo de nuevas infraestructuras".

En su opinión, la participación ciudadana "no se puede limitar" al rechazo a ETA y al compromiso con el diálogo democrático, sino que es preciso "confiar en la madurez" de la sociedad vasca para decidir su futuro "en un sentido amplio". "Y el nacionalismo ha de asumir este reto con convicción para que su apuesta por la participación ciudadana resulte creíble", reivindica.

Por otro lado, emplaza al PSOE a que "marque distancias" con el Partido Popular y "recupere, de una vez por todas, sus señas de identidad" porque "la izquierda no puede renunciar a la participación ciudadana como expresión de democracia real". En un contexto en el que "todos los países de nuestro entorno avanzan en políticas de participación ciudadana", EB estima que "no es comprensible ni razonable la negativa del PSOE y su alianza con el Partido Popular en contra de la democracia real", que en Euskadi es "una demanda social mayoritaria".

ADHESIÓN

Finalmente, Ezker Batua-Berdeak realiza un llamamiento a toda la ciudadanía vasca para que muestre su adhesión a todas las iniciativas políticas y sociales que se lleven a cabo en defensa de la participación ciudadana y aboga por la puesta en marcha de una campaña informativa que "contribuya a desmontar todas las tergiversaciones urdidas por el PSOE y el PP, que juegan a la confusión y a la manipulación, presentando como verdades lo que son burdas mentiras".

La formación de izquierdas apela al desarrollo de "un trabajo serio y profundo de pedagogía social para que la ciudadanía sepa que una consulta no vinculante no es un referéndum y que el Proyecto de Ley aprobado en la Parlamento vasco es legítimo, democrático y legal".

"Presentar esta iniciativa como un acto rupturista, soberanista o independentista no sólo es falso; constituye, además, un fraude y un engaño a la sociedad, con el único objetivo de negar e impedir en Euskadi que la ciudadanía puede decir a ETA que se disuelva por y para siempre, y al conjunto de partido políticos que la solución a nuestros problemas pasa necesariamente por el cese definitivo de la violencia y el diálogo democrático", concluye.

Philippines: Struggling with Direct Democracy

Valdehuesa: Ignorance makes ours a “bonsai” republic

By Manuel Valdehuesa
Monday, September 15, 2008

Street Talk
Source: http://www.sunstar.com.ph/static/cag/2008/09/15/oped/manuel.valdehuesa.street.talk.html

We’ve dealt with the barangay as a government, as a corporation, and as an economy. Anyone who doesn’t know why these three aspects are important or how each is supposed to be managed has no business demanding or preaching about good governance. And any official who doesn’t know how to make each one functional has no business staying in office.

What's your take on the Mindanao crisis? Discuss views with other readers

It’s been over a decade and a half since the Local Government Code of 1991 became law. It was meant 1) to correct the imbalance of power between the national and the local, 2) to lessen excessive centralization at the top, 3) to devolve what properly should be exercised by the intermediate and primary levels of government, and 4) to empower the community by giving the people an official role in overseeing its affairs.

But while the first three are substantially operative, the fourth and most important for the proper functioning of democracy – empowerment -- has been ignored. The people are still uninvolved, powerless, unable to participate in governance. Instead they are controlled and manipulated by the barangay chairman and his cohorts. And it’s all due to ignorance.

Ignorance about the barangay as a government -- with a direct democracy and a parliamentary form -- has turned it into an oligarchy of mostly incompetent officials that feed on its income. Ignorant chairmen not only trivialize the role of the people, they arrogate their power and govern the community arbitrarily, turning the kagawads and the sangguniang kabataan into puppets. Equally ignorant of their role, the citizens are mere spectators instead of actors in local governance. Even civil society seems clueless; they’re focused on the upper governments.

The legislative governing body called Barangay Assembly -- the local parliament consisting of all adult residents -- does not convene or hold deliberations. The people themselves are ignorant of their role in it. Failing to meet or decide collectively, the community cannot determine let alone express its collective will. It cannot form a consensus on anything. Voiceless, they are helpless, vulnerable to manipulation by the forces of corruption.

Worse, the leading citizens surrender the community’s fate to power-obsessed little trapos. They reinforce the barangay chairman’s thinking that he is a little president/commander-in-chief when in fact he is a little prime minister presiding over a parliamentary government -- with the people as members of parliament; as such they’re supposed to be the foil against abuse by the chairman. It is a non-performing government.

Ignorance about the barangay as a corporation makes it rely on subsidies, mainly on the internal revenue allotment (IRA) -- which the officials spend like an allowance instead of as capital for development. Clueless about the barangay’s corporate powers, they don’t organize enterprises to generate their own revenues. They do not enter into joint ventures with other barangays or tap private equity to capitalize enterprises including cooperatives, micro-lending or even a modest public utility like a water system, a shuttle service to and from the market, to and from the school, or wherever people need to be ferried. The idea of a subsidiary company to develop profitable opportunities is alien to them. They have overseas workers interested in ventures to create employment or income for those left behind, but there’s no initiative to do so. It’s a non-performing corporation.

As an economy, there is no attempt to explore the development of their land, labor or capital. They don’t inventory resources. Rural barangays don’t exploit opportunities offered by their nature-rich and exotic areas -- for ecotourism, recreation, adventure, or agribusiness. There are tropical beaches, lush forests, rolling plains, winding rivers, and underground wealth that are neglected. If at all, these are exploited by economic predators who strip their environment and leave nothing for future generations. Even their forest products and herbal goods are taken right under their noses to be exported or patented, depriving generations of their present and future value. It’s a non-performing economy.

Urban barangays neglect the production, marketing or financing possibilities in their own backyard. Entrepreneurs, craftsmen and assorted talents in their neighborhoods cry out to be discovered or supported but are ignored. Their fate is left to opportunists that trawl the community and strip it of its human and other resources.

Barangays form the base on which our republic’s politics and economics is built. But ignorance about the people’s role in it and the failure to develop it is making it a “bonsai” republic!

Ask Arturo Sanvictores, Ed Layug, Ruben Vegafria, or Hernan Agpawa why this is so! #

A former UN executive and director at the development academy of the Philippines, Manny heads the Gising Barangay Movement and writes Mondays, Wednesday, Fridays.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Direct Democracy in Taiwan and China

Taiwan needs change in parliamentary majority

By Dennis Engbarth
Taiwan News, Staff Writer
Page 4
2008-10-14 12:59 AM


Source: http://www.etaiwannews.com/etn/news_content.php?id=762247

A researcher in the development of referendums, initiatives and other methods of direct democracy since the 1970s, Professor Theo Schiller of the department of political science at Phillips University in Marburg, Germany, is chairman of the supervisory committee for the Initiative and Referendum Institute (IRI) - Europe.


After convening a major conference on "World Direct Democracy" in Aarau, Switzerland, Schiller discussed the potential and the problems of direct democracy methods for "democratizing democracy" in Europe and Asia, including Taiwan.

Q: Some proponents say that direct democracy can do everything that representative democracy does and does it better. Do you agree?

A: Representative democracy must provide the foundation for any democratic system. Direct democracy cannot replace representative democracy, but direct democracy methods can improve and supplement the political processes in representative democracies; and inject new life into representative systems by providing procedures which allow citizens to raise issues on decision-making agenda without the mediation of political parties through "popular initiatives" that may become referendums; or to settle an issue by a direct popular vote through referendum instead of parliamentary procedures. In representative democracies, there are always some areas that are overlooked or neglected so there is always a certain lack of responsiveness in representative systems. In these neglected areas of political life, direct democracy methods can help to articulate the interests of minorities or neglected groups of people, and such people can use direct democracy to push for improvements and innovations.

Q: Most European countries incorporate some forms of direct democracy, but is there any potential for the use of direct democracy at the EU level?

A: The European Union political system is not yet a complete representative democratic system, but a deficit or a secondary representative democracy that is far less representative than the systems of EU member countries. At present, we cannot see how the European political system can develop toward full-scale representative democracy and therefore there is even more need for direct democracy in Europe on the European level than in the individual national democracies. Ideally, we would need direct democracy on the European level in two forms. First, we need the right of popular or people's initiative and the institution of "optional referendum" through which EU citizens would be able to affirm or reject legislation on a EU level. However, at the current phase of political development in the EU, we will not get these rights. However, the proposed "European Citizen Initiative" which is contained in the proposed Treaty of Lisbon is a very first step. The ECI will be only a kind of "agenda initiative" through which one million people can put an initiative on the political agenda through their signatures on an initiative petition and is a very small first step to begin a development toward more direct democracy on the European level. I believe it is very important to get the Treaty of Lisbon, which has been stalled by its rejection by referendum in Ireland in June, ratified and the ECI implemented so that citizens in the EU will be able to use this first truly European transnational instrument of direct democracy.

Q: What lessons can we learn from the experience of the Swiss system of direct democracy?

A: Switzerland is a special case with a long history of direct democracy. In most other European countries and other parts of the world, we are still a long way from formulating the rules and to have the courage to give access to these methods of direct democracy not just to majorities or large minorities but also to small groups so they can initiate and put new issues on the agenda and stir up new debates and deliberations. And there must also be much time for discussions by citizens on initiatives or referendums in society because only on the basis of thorough discussion and debate can the quality of direct democracy methods be developed.

Q: What is your assessment of the prospects of direct democracy in the new democracies in Eastern Europe?

A: Instruments of direct democracy were introduced in Eastern Europe, especially in those countries which strived for independence such as the Baltic nations of Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia as well as Slovakia and Slovenia. In connection with gaining independence, they had a concept that democratic transformation was a process of the whole nation and therefore they set the rules for using people's initiatives very high because they felt that initiatives or referendums should only be used by large majorities so as not to allow any small group the right of initiative. But this belief has proven to be wrong. These high thresholds now block the use of direct democracy instruments which cannot have any utility beyond consolidation of power. Unless these countries lower or eliminate unreasonable thresholds on petitions and turnout quorums, it will be impossible for direct democracy methods to realize their most important function, which is to give the right of people's initiative to minorities so that they can articulate neglected interests and values.

Q: What is your evaluation of the experience of Asian countries with direct democracy methods?

A: In a general way, the experience in most Asian countries has been similar to that of Eastern Europe, but in Asia, there are also several countries with rather authoritarian systems in which the transformation of the power structures has not even begun, including places like Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam, not to mention China or Burma. Other countries, such as Taiwan, South Korea and the Philippines, have instruments of direct democracy, but the context of the transformation of the whole power system has yet to be developed further.

Q: Does this pessimistic evaluation hold for Taiwan as well?

A: If you look at Taiwan comparatively in terms of democratic development, what is surely necessary is one or two changes in the parliamentary majority. So far, we have had two periods in which the president and the executive branch were controlled by a different party than the traditional power but in which the parliamentary majority did not change. What is very important is that there should be a change in the parliamentary majority because such a change in the parliamentary majority is a necessary condition for a genuine democratic transformation. In that period, it may be possible to deal with some issues in the reform of direct democracy and the current referendum law, but direct democracy may even be a factor bringing this process forward. However, changes of power in the Executive branch are not enough. Unless there is a change in the parliamentary majority, the democratic transformation will remain incomplete. However, it is clear that external factors and external relations can greatly influence the internal chances for such a transformation.

Q: Taiwan had two referenda together with the January legislative elections and the March presidential election that were nominally initiatives but promoted by the then governing Democratic Progressive Party. How do you evaluate their significance?

A: People's initiatives from the bottom that lead to referendums are in the last analysis more important than plebiscites or other referendums from the top down in securing democratic transformations. Even if referendums initiated by the people from the bottom up lose, they are very valuable as they activate participation of the citizens. Even if the two referendums earlier this year did not gain valid passage, they still have a legacy of having activated citizen participation and so they can contribute to the process of the development of democracy in Taiwan.

Q: What are the prospects for direct democracy in the People's Republic of China?

A: Before anything else, China needs to have guarantees of fundamental human and political rights and the rule of law and guarantees that citizens who are molested by the government or other authorities can gain redress in court. These conditions are not fulfilled in the PRC but if they do not exist, you cannot really begin to act politically as a free citizen. Until guarantees for the free expression of opinion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly in public places, freedom of forming political associations and other basic rights are realized, there will be no room for having any meaningful democracy.

ARGENTINA: Encuentro Nacional de Presupuestos Participativos

PRESUPUESTOS PARTICIPATIVOS-CONVENIO

ANUNCIAN ENCUENTRO NACIONAL DE PRESUPUESTOS PARTICIPATIVOS


Política 21:08:00
Fuente:
http://www.elpatagonico.net/index.php?item=viewlast&ref=ultimas&id=96106&sec=pol

Buenos Aires, 7 de octubre El Secretario de Relaciones Parlamentarias de la Jefatura de Gabinete de Ministros de la Nación, Oscar González, y el Intendente de la ciudad de La Plata, Pablo Bruera, suscribieron hoy un convenio de cooperación para organizar conjuntamente el "Primer Encuentro Nacional de Presupuestos Participativos", que se realizará en esa ciudad los días 12, 13 y 14 de diciembre próximo.

"Desde la Jefatura de Gabinete queremos aprovechar la excelente disposición del intendente Bruera para que funcionarios, dirigentes sociales y especialistas en Presupuesto Participativo socialicen experiencias y compartan ideas en torno a este instrumento tan importante de la democracia directa", dijo González.

"Precisamente -añadió- una de las misiones de la Secretaría de Relaciones Parlamentarias es fomentar el protagonismo popular mediante la implementación de estas nuevas herramientas de participación que acompañan y enriquecen los métodos tradicionales de la democracia representativa".

Por su parte, Bruera explicó que "este apoyo del Gobierno Nacional posibilitará que las diferentes ciudades del país, y algunas del exterior puedan venir a contar sus experiencias y mejorar la propuesta porque es muy importante seguir perfeccionándola".

En ese sentido, el intendente resaltó que "estamos en plena ejecución de los 35 proyectos elegidos en el mes de junio. Y para el congreso de diciembre ya estarán todas las obras terminadas. Además, antes de fin de año convocaremos a una nueva votación para ejecutarse en el 2009, con el doble de presupuesto para realizar obras".

"Este sistema además tiene el control de cada uno de los vecinos, porque cada uno de los proyectos fueron propuestos por ellos mismos y eso ayuda mucho a que nos enteremos si llega a haber una dificultad en su realización. Eso nos permitió que en muchos barrios podamos hacer también el segundo proyecto votado por lo vecinos", finalizó el Jefe Comunal.

La firma del convenio tuvo lugar en el Salón de Acuerdos municipal de La Plata, durante un acto del que también participaron entre otros Mario Rodríguez, Secretario General de la Municipalidad de La Plata, Carlos Sortino, Secretario del Consejo de Presupuesto Participativo platense y el responsable del programa de Presupuesto Participativo de la Secretaría de Relaciones Parlamentarias, Pablo Caruso.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

ESPAÑA: VI Jornadas Internacionales de Presupuestos Participativos de Sevilla

VI JORNADAS INTERNACIONALES SOBRE PRESUPUESTOS PARTICIPATIVOS EN SEVILLA

HACIA LA CIUDADANÍA TOTAL: INCLUSIÓN SOCIAL Y PRESUPUESTOS PARTICIPATIVOS Del 5 al 8 de Noviembre de 2008
Fuente:
http://www.presupuestosparticipativos.com/

Desde el inicio del presupuesto participativo en Sevilla hay un creciente interés por la participación de aquellos colectivos que han sido históricamente subrepresentados o excluidos de la toma de decisiones en lo público. Una necesidad de democratizar la vida de las ciudades ampliando la participación precisamente a aquellos sectores y colectivos apartados de la cosa pública como las mujeres, los inmigrantes, los mayores, los jóvenes, los discapacitados…

Ya hemos andado algo, pero nos falta mucho por hacer. Por eso estas VI Jornadas Internacionales de Presupuestos Participativos de Sevilla quiere reflexionar sobre esto, además de otras cuestiones, y para esto hemos invitado a personalidades, activistas e investigadores de otras partes del Mundo para que nos acompañen en esta labor de reflexión y profundización y nos ayuden en esta apuesta por la inclusión social. Y en este debate, tú tampoco puedes faltar. Participa.

VER TRÍPTICO:
sevilla.iepala.es/suelto/tripvijor.pdf

COLOMBIA: The Referendum that would Allow a Third Term for Uribe in 2010


In a recent post we featured a scheduled referendum in Colombia desiged to protect water rights. Another more contentious initiative that will be put on the ballot next year would amend the country's constitution in order to allow President Alvaro Uribe to run for a third consecutive term in 2010. When Hugo Chavez of Venezuela attempted to include a similar measure on term limits in a referendum package of constitutional reforms, he was widely criticized by his opponents as being an authoritarian dictator. Some are now levelling the same criticism at Alvaro Uribe of Colombia for his refusal to rule out a third term and denounce the referendum. - Editor

Colombia's Uribe eyes one more run

Enjoying great popularity after suppressing guerrilla violence, Colombia's president has declined to discourage a movement to let him run for a third term.

BY JOHN OTIS
Houston Chronicle
Source: http://www.miamiherald.com/news/world/latin-america-and-caribbean-politics/story/708316.html



BOGOTA -- Will he or won't he?

Halfway through his second term, Alvaro Uribe, Colombia's wildly popular president, remains coy about whether he will seek a third four-year term in 2010.

Earlier this month, he strongly hinted he would sit out the next election and perhaps attempt a comeback in 2014. Days later, Uribe said he might run in 2010 if his political allies failed to unite behind a single candidate who would continue his hard-line security policies.

Uribe has done nothing to stop a citizen-based drive to change the Colombian Constitution to allow him to run again. For the moment, the charter prohibits presidents from serving more than two terms.

But this month, the Colombian Congress received a petition with more than five million signatures obliging lawmakers to consider a referendum on eliminating the ban on third terms.

''People say that he's doing good work and, if that's the case, he should continue in the job,'' said Carlos Alberto Jaramillo, one of the organizers of the petition drive.

RIDING HIGH

Many analysts believe Uribe would win if allowed to run.

Thanks to a string of military victories against the country's Marxist guerillas, Uribe is riding high in the polls. A Gallup survey puts his job-approval rating at 78 percent.

But critics warn that Uribe could damage his reputation and Colombia's close relations with the United States by seeking three consecutive terms.

Latin America has a history of military dictators. Thus, when democracy spread across the region in the late 1980s and early '90s, the constitutions of many of these nations were rewritten to prohibit presidential re-election.

Uribe engineered one constitutional change that allowed him to run for a second term in 2006. That effort led to allegations that members of his Cabinet had secured congressional support by promising jobs and other favors to legislators.

Going for a third term in 2010 ''would display an authoritarian tendency,'' said Michael Shifter of the Inter-American Dialogue think tank in Washington. ``It would also hurt his legacy which, on balance, has been very positive.''

Uribe has been vague, keeping all of his options on the table and thus avoiding the handicap of becoming a lame-duck leader.

Speaking before a university audience, he said he preferred to promote new leaders and to improve national security during his remaining two years in office and that the reelection issue would be a distraction.

''I think it's much better that Colombians consolidate the policies of democratic security, investor confidence and social cohesion rather than worry about the president remaining in power,'' he said.
Shortly afterward, however, he indicated he would run should the campaign of the would-be successor from his political coalition falter.

But Uribe's maneuvering has prevented Defense Minister Juan Manuel Santos and other pro-government candidates from launching their own campaigns, which could provide an opening for the opposition.

First sworn in in 2002, then reelected in 2006 by a landslide, Uribe made his mark by improving security in a nation plagued by kidnappings and where left-wing guerrillas and right-wing paramilitaries held control of huge swaths of the countryside.

ENLARGED ARMY

Uribe added more than 100,000 troops to the armed forces. They have captured or killed key guerrilla leaders while thousands of paramilitaries have disarmed.

The military's most spectacular feat was a July 2 operation that rescued 15 high-profile hostages, including former presidential candidate Ingrid Betancourt and three U.S. military contractors.

ECONOMY IMPROVED

Although the illegal drug trade remains robust, improved security has brought more tourism and foreign investment to Colombia and sparked six years of economic growth.

Still, everyone from Uribe's advisers to leading businessmen and his wife reportedly have urged him to step down in 2010.

''We shouldn't confuse the admiration that the business community has for Uribe with the danger of extending his rule longer than is advisable,'' said Luis Carlos Villegas, president of ANDI, an influential business association.

CLOUDS LINGER

Uribe has been weakened by a long-running investigation into ties between paramilitaries and his political allies in the Congress. Nearly 70 legislators, almost all of them pro-Uribe, are either in prison or under investigation, a scandal that has led to calls for the election of a new Congress.

In addition, Uribe has feuded with Supreme Court justices investigating the paramilitary scandal, has traded insults with former Colombian presidents and accused human rights organizations of working with the guerrillas.

''The president should consider taking a break to re-charge his batteries,'' declared a recent editorial in the

Bogotá newspaper El

Tiempo.

Friday, October 24, 2008

ECUADOR: La participación del pueblo rige en la nueva Constitución

La participación del pueblo rige en la nueva Constitución

En el proyecto de nueva Constitución el pueblo ecuatoriano participará en la toma de decisiones públicas y privadas. El pueblo actuará en todos los niveles de gobierno.

Edison Solis Quito- Ecuador 5-9-2008 67 lecturas

Fuente: www.kaosenlared.net/noticia/participacion-pueblo-rige-nueva-constitucion

En el proyecto de nueva Constitución, que entrará a referéndum el próximo 28 de septiembre, existen varios artículos que permiten al pueblo ecuatoriano, a través de representantes de organizaciones populares, a formar parte de la toma de decisiones, planificación y gestión de los asuntos públicos.

El título cuarto, que se refiere a la Participación y Organización del Poder, establece claramente, en la mayoría de articulados, que este derecho, que ha sido pisoteado por los gobiernos neoliberales, se cumpla en esta nueva Constitución. Algo que a decir de varios analistas, asesores y dirigentes populares, es un proyecto Constitucional donde ha participado el pueblo ecuatoriano.

Así lo confirma Patricio Torres, asesor del asambleísta por el Movimiento Popular Democrático (MPD), Jorge Escala, quien indica que, entre otros artículos, el 95 define la participación de forma individual y colectiva en la toma de decisiones de los asuntos públicos. Agrega que, además de éste importante derecho, se establece un control de las instituciones del Estado, de la sociedad y de sus representantes. El letrado indica que se reconoce todo forma de organización y control como expresión de la soberanía popular.

“Entre aspectos más relevantes se encuentra el artículo 98 donde los individuos y los colectivos podrán ejercer el derecho a la resistencia frente a acciones u omisiones del poder público y demandar el reconocimiento de nuevos derechos. Además, se establece que todos los niveles de gobierno estarán integrados por instancias de participación ciudadana de elección popular” indica Torres.

Uno de los artículos que con mayor énfasis es reconocido por este asesor es el 119 donde se reconoce que para ser asambleísta se requerirá tener nacionalidad ecuatoriana, gozar de los derechos ciudadanos, y especialmente, tener 18 años. Según Torres, a esto se suma el voto optativo para los jóvenes que tengas 16 años y es proceso histórico en Ecuador y el Mundo. Indica que en esta constitución se reconoce el papel de las luchas populares y académicas para forjar un pensamiento que plantee la transformación de este sistema.

En cuanto a las formas de democracia directa, específicamente a la consulta popular, permite que ésta se realice a petición de la ciudadanía sin reforma constitucional cuando se haya logrado la adhesión del ocho por ciento del padrón electoral. Por lo tanto, la consulta popular será un mecanismo para que el pueblo se pronuncie para realizar reformas Constitucionales o aspectos locales. Entre varios de los artículos que toman en cuenta al poder del pueblo como mandante y primer fiscalizador se encuentran los artículos 96, 100,101, 108,111, 120, 204, 208.

Para el Presidente de la Federación Única Nacional del Seguro Social Campesino (Feunassc), Byron Garcés, el proyecto de Constitución es democrático y participativo porque recogió las propuestas de todos los sectores, especialmente, de los campesinos. Asegura que siempre han luchado de hecho para que el movimiento campesino participe en la toma de decisiones fundamentales para su organización, sin embargo, afirma que ahora en el nuevo proyecto de Constitución se reconoce a su lucha no solo de hecho sino también de derecho. Agrega que antes las comunidades campesinas que no tienen acceso a las tierras para que los organismos correspondientes puedan atender sus pedidos, pero que ahora, además de vigilar la gestión de las instituciones públicas, exigirán que luchen por adquirir nuevos derechos y se cumplan con sus nuevas exigencias.

“Me parece muy oportuno que ahora los sectores populares podamos realizar veedurías directas de la cosa pública. Es positivo además que se reconozca a la organización colectiva de la sociedad porque antes solo eran tomadas en cuenta aquellas que funcionaban con el carácter de derecho, ahora pueden funcionar también las de hecho. Sin embargo, la base social será aquella que reconozca la labor de sus dirigentes” manifestó el titular de la Feunassc.

Agrega que existirá el Consejo de Participación Ciudadana y Control Social donde deberá estar integrada por las personas y organizaciones más probas y de aquellas que han mantenido una lucha histórica. Asegura que no estarían de acuerdo que formen parte de este Consejo algunos representantes ONG’s cuestionados por la opinión pública.