We received the following press release from the Zambia Direct Democracy Movement. - Editor
Zambia Direct Democracy
Movement-ZDDM
P.O BOX 34553
Contact 0977-621364
Lusaka
8th October, 2008
Its Not Too Late to Save Zambia
Zambians are ill prepared for the forth-coming Presidential election and going ahead with it may have serious long term consequences for our nation hence our appealing to the listed institutions and key stakeholders to support our call that the Zambia Centre for Inter-party Dialogue-ZCID may initiate dialogue which can lead to the formation of a Government of National Unity which can simply bring all the contenders and other party leaders into government.
* Zambian Government
* MMD Secretariat
* PF Secretariat
* UPND Secretariat
* American Embassy
* British Embassy
* Swedish Embassy
* The Roman Catholic Secretariat
We believe that the forth-coming election to be held as stipulated by the current sick constitution can be set aside to allow reason to dictate because this will not only be an unnecessary waste of resources but an exercise which will not help to bring about the kind of change which Zambians desperately need.
Contrary to what some people may believe an agreement by all political parties at the ZCID followed up by a letter to Electoral Commission of Zambia, ECZ and the High Court is all that it needs to start a Healing process for our country. This can be the much needed Fresh Start towards Zambia becoming a Great Nation with the unfortunately lost vision already stated in our National Anthem.
Already for our young people and those who have suffered serious mental injury under the current government, the election is viewed as a chance to express their anger while for some it has been reduced to a situation where they will want to express their tribal solidarity.
The Mwanawasa era used excessive force by the police and courts to silence citizens for a long time and it is in national interest that a Government of National unity is put in place to defuse deeply rooted anger being harbored by many citizens such as the youth whose Themba's and survival efforts were destroyed, many retirees who have not been paid their due since 1991 when the MMD came in power, the suffering unemployed, those whose homes have been destroyed, and indeed many who feel that they have been victims of injustice etc. Holding elections at this point in time and using a constitution which the nation has already agreed needs a complete overhaul will defeat the whole purpose and reason of the exercise and reduce the election into a mere protest.
Already some citizens are threatening to withhold their votes if their immediate concern such as water and electricity load shedding is not minimized. ZDDM believes that the formation of a Government of National unity can help reduce the current tension in the country and pave way for the establishment of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission to visit all cases of alleged injustices stretching back to the UNIP era can be addressed as part of the healing process.
It would also pave way for establishing a genuine fight against corruption as compared to the current selective and politically motivated anti-corruption fight where some citizens are imprisoned for the theft of cars which nobody and not even the convicted, the police or the institution were the alleged theft was done are aware of.
Zambians have not enjoyed their freedom of expression because the public media is still controlled by government and the security forces have reacted with excessive force to discourage this mode of expression which has left many citizens looking forward to vent out their anger and frustration through the vote.
As already explained Zambia will be gambling with its future by going ahead with this election before serious concerns from citizens are addressed, a new constitution is put in place and those aspiring for Presidency explain their manifestos because all that the nation is getting from politicians right now are insults and demonisation of each other. The nation requires a massive education on why citizens should vote and promote a realization of the power of the vote and it is only when this is done and really appreciated that Zambians will be able to hold meaningful elections which can facilitate a common vision for Zambians to engage in a battle to save the nation from deepening poverty and address its serious social, moral, political and economic crisis which has been created by the now accepted culture of wasting valuable time and energy on pointing accusation fingers at each other.
In spite of our country being among the richest countries on the continent it is now listed among the poorest countries with among the highest poverty related death rate because of our failure to engage in serious and constructive dialogue. Our Movement believes that it is in national interest that the remaining 30 month of the term of office of this government can be utilized to making a deliberate effort to pave way for a Better Zambia.
It is against this background that ZDDM even at this late hour is mobilizing support that the ZCID can bring together its members contesting the election that they may save the nation unnecessary expenditure and acrimony by changing the future of Zambia through the creation of a Government of National Unity which can focus on a collective national effort to addressing the crisis facing the nation.
Our Politicians should acknowledge the fact that no single person or party can single handedly save Zambia from its current situation .This task needs the coordinated effort of every Zambian from politician to the simple villager in the remote.
We pray that the opposition parties will take heed of our advice this time because they are most likely going to regret if they ignore this advice as it is becoming very clear that the Acting-Vice President Mr. Rupiah Banda will win with a landslide due to the obvious mistakes being made by the opposition.
ZDDM just like many other Zambians is extremely disappointed that the country has been turned into a political battle field of insults and demonizing each other because this does not inspire hope or indeed save any constructive purpose. Zambians do not like what is going on and contrary to what those engaged in this crusade think-they are helping to draw a lot of sympathy and support for Vice-President Banda who is already being viewed as a victim of Satanic attacks. His reaction to the insults being hailed at him is already proving that he is mature and a very democratic leader who does not even need to rig the election results because Zambians are now apprehensive of what sort of government they may have if some candidates won.
While the opposition conduct is campaigning for the Acting President, Zambians should also ask themselves if those demonizing him will accept the landslide victory which they are building for him ?.
ZDDM believes that a time has come for Zambians to put their personal and partisan interest aside to serve a bigger cause which is Zambia as a nation. A government with Mr. Rupiah Banda, Mr. Michael Sata, Mr. Hichilema Hakainde, Mr. Nevers Mumba, Brigadier Miyanda, Mr. Enock Kavindele, Mr. Mundia Sikatana, Princes Nakatindi and all the opposition parties for the remaining 30 months can be very powerful and capable of healing this nation that the year 2011 can give Zambia a Fresh beginning full of hope.
Instead of having a winner and losers ZDDM and indeed the whole nation stands to win if all the political parties for once in Zambian history can put aside their interest and agree to work as one to heal our country and stop the current unnecessary widespread abject poverty .
United we Stand as a Nation
Divided we shall continue to fight and witness
unnecessary premature deaths
Edwin Sakala
National Coordinator for Zambia Direct Democracy
Movement-ZDDM
And at the same time
Chairman of Movement for African Unity-MAU
AND
Southern African Regional Representative for the
General Forum for Arab-African NGOs
PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY vs REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY
Over the decades, our representative democracy has been systematically undermined and has ultimately failed in preserving the well being of the people of this nation. The system that the founding fathers painstakingly devised in order to best serve the interests and the will of the people has been corrupted and the systems of checks and balances on power that they instituted have been stripped away. Most of us accept this reality as being beyond our control and continue to observe, comment, and complain without aspiring to achieving any real change, without any hope of instituting a new system of governance that would instead take directly into account your views, and the views of your neighbors, and would empower you to make real positive change possible in your communities.
This site will attempt to explore in depth the places in the world where people are successfully bringing about that type of change in the face of similar odds, where an alternate form of democracy, which is called participatory or direct democracy, is taking root. Initiative, referendum & recall, community councils, and grassroots organizing are but a few ways in which direct/participatory democracy is achieving great success around the world.
Our system of representative democracy does not admit the voice of the people into congressional halls, the high courts, or the oval office where our rights and our liberties are being sold out from underneath us. Our local leaders and activists in our communities, and even those local elected officials who may have the best of intentions are for the most part powerless to make real positive change happen in our neighborhoods, towns and villages when there is so much corruption from above.
In places like Venezuela, Argentina, Bolivia, Nicaragua, Ecuador, Brazil, South Africa, India, and the Phillipines, new experiments in grass roots community based governance are taking place. There is much to be learned from these and other examples of participatory democracy from around the world when we try to examine how this grass-roots based governance could begin to take root here in our own country in order to alter our political system so that it might better serve the American people.
In the hope that one day we can become a nation working together as a united people practicing true democracy as true equals, we open this forum…
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
ZAMBIA: Struggles Toward a New Era
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
7:58 PM
0
comments
Labels: AFRICA, Direct Democracy, ZAMBIA, ZDDM
Monday, October 13, 2008
EU: Lisbon Treaty Would Bring Trans-border Direct Democracy
The Lisbon Treaty, if approved, contains a provision that would see the current spread of direct democracy in the E.U. achieve a new dimension. If enough signatures are gathered, a referendum can be held on new or existing E.U. laws. This would be the first example of referendum trancending national borders as the votte would be held in multiple countries simultaneously. -Editor
Source: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/public/story_page/008-38745-338-12-49-901-20081006STO38717-2008-03-12-2008/default_en.htm
"1 million voices, 1 Message, End poverty": German Chancellor Merkel in June '07
Discussions by MEPs on the Constitutional Affairs Committee on 18 September come ahead of a report on the subject by Sylvia-Yvonne Kaufmann of the GUE/NGL group. She believes the legal position needs clarification.
Democratic "directness" appreciated
The introduction of such a system by the reform treaty would make it the first example of direct democracy between several different countries.
MEPs heard from many NGO representatives who said the move would make the EU's institutions more open to people. Several speakers thought that not just EU citizens but people who are resident in the Union should also be allowed to take part.
One million signatures represents 0.2% of the EU population. There was some discussion about whether it should be exactly 1 million (for example is 970,000 acceptable?) - and how many countries it should come from.
Don't set hurdle of participation too high
Professor Jürgen Meyer, a former member of the Bundestag said that the 1 million mark gave it weight but did not set the hurdle too high.
There was also some debate about how to collect signatures, how they should be verified and how long people should have to collect them. Whether electronic signatures were acceptable and should people give their address were also issues.
The chair of the Constitutional Affairs Committee, German Socialist Jo Leinen thought the signature idea would lead to more involvement by people in the running of the EU. He hoped the reform treaty would be adopted before the European parliamentary elections in June next year.
Ms Kaufmann said the initiative opens the door for direct democracy and is a new legal tool. She also said that it was important to draw on the legal traditions across different countries and cultures.
The report is expected by January.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
11:05 PM
0
comments
Labels: Direct Democracy, EUROPE, European Union, GERMANY, Initiative and Referendum
EL SALVADOR: Funes Propone la Democracia Directa y Participativa para El Salvador
Funes copia mensaje de sandinista Ortega
El Diario de Hoy
Miércoles, 8 de Octubre de 2008
El candidato presidencial del FMLN, Mauricio Funes, reforzó la intención de su partido de cambiar el actual sistema democrático por uno de democracia directa al estilo del sandinismo en Nicaragua, en donde el poder lo tiene "el pueblo".
"La pregunta de quién manda en el FMLN: la dirección del FMLN o Mauricio Funes. ¡Ninguno de los dos! Va a mandar el pueblo", aseguró el aspirante farabundista durante una conferencia sobre el Estado de Derecho al que lo invitó la Fundación de Estudios para la Aplicación del Derecho (Fespad).
Esa frase, pronunciada el martes ante estudiantes de la UCA, va en consonancia con las intenciones del nicaragüense Daniel Ortega de romper con la "democracia burguesa" e instalar una "democracia popular directa".
Incluso, en uno de los afiches del nicaragüense se puede leer: "El pueblo, Presidente" (ver foto).
Pese a que Funes manifestó en esa misma conferencia que "no respiro por la nariz de (Hugo) Chávez, (Daniel) Ortega ni Evo (Morales)", se mostró a favor de "un nuevo estilo de gobernar" en la cual habría "debate" en las instituciones del Estado.
"Necesitamos condiciones para la existencia de políticas de participación ciudadana basada en apertura de espacios y mecanismos de diálogo y consulta de ciudadanos", diría más tarde el ex presentador de televisión.
En la plataforma de gobierno de Funes, en el capítulo de la reforma política, hay varios párrafos considerados vagos por algunos juristas y que podrían dar pie a un experimento de "democracia directa" al estilo de Venezuela o Cuba, en donde los comités de cuadra, barrio o colonia, ejercen una suerte de poder paralelo a las instituciones y que, en aras de la soberanía popular, se vuelven sistemas totalitarios.
La plataforma establece que "El país necesita una reforma del Estado en su doble dimensión: como sistema de instituciones y como sistema de organizaciones públicas".
Ese párrafo, a juicio de algunos analistas, deja la puerta abierta a un ejercicio que no está establecido en la Constitución salvadoreña, pero que puede crear organismos paralelos al Estado.
Admite pugna
Funes admitió ante los estudiantes que mantuvo un pulso con la dirigencia por el reenganche en la diputación de Salvador Arias, con quien mantuvo diferencias en temas como la dolarización.
"Les preocupa si Salvador Arias iba o no iba como diputado y quién ganaba el pulso", deslizó cuando reclamaba por qué los periodistas no dan importancia a temas que a él le interesan.
La revelación la hizo cuando intentaba justificar por qué no responde a las preguntas que le incomodan y, en su lugar, trata de imponer su agenda a los medios informativos.
"A algunos (medios de comunicación) les he dado sugerencias profesionales, no les he impuesto nada; les he dicho que si quieren estar en sintonía con la población deberían de recrear los problemas que más le preocupan a la población", dijo el farabundista.
En ese contexto, también admitió que no se puede dejar de comentar la realidad de otros países, aunque con frecuencia se niegue a opinar sobre las actuaciones, por ejemplo, del venezolano Hugo Chávez, y, sin mencionarlo, criticó la expulsión de dos observadores de la Ong Human Rights Watch de Caracas.
"Yo no expulsaría a Human Rights porque den un informe que cuestione mi sistema de gobierno. Lo toleraría. Si el presidente Chávez lo ha hecho, que lo juzgue el pueblo de Venezuela", dijo el ex presentador de TV.
Funes también mandó un recado a la dirigencia, cuando un estudiante le cuestionó sobre qué tipo de personas llevaría para un posible gobierno del FMLN.
"No hay cuotas partidarias. No van a llegar por ser del FMLN", dijo el candidato rojo.
También justificó que la dirigencia no le permitiera incluir a los "Amigos de Mauricio" como candidatos a diputados.
Explicó que se trata de un movimiento nuevo y que, por estatutos, los aspirantes a una diputación deben tener una militancia de al menos cuatro años en el FMLN.
Sin embargo, la cúpula del FMLN sopesó, a principios del año, la idea de modificar los estatutos para abrir las listas a los foráneos. Funes no tuvo éxito en su intentó de abrir el FMLN a los no militantes rojos.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
10:46 PM
0
comments
Labels: Democracia Participativa, El Salvador, Mauricio Funes
Saturday, October 11, 2008
ESPAÑA: ¿Quién Teme a los Referendos?
LA CLAVE
Ferran Requejo - 21/09/2008
Los procesos de democracia directa han ido adquiriendo relevancia en los últimos años, tanto en el ámbito de la teoría democrática como en el de la política práctica. Su objetivo es superar parte de las limitaciones participativas de la democracia liberal clásica. En algunos estados, la participación de los ciudadanos se circunscribe a los procesos electorales, limitando los referendos a casos muy específicos. Es el caso de la Constitución española de 1978, que regula de modo muy restrictivo la participación ciudadana en referendos. Esta es una más de las deficiencias institucionales del texto constitucional actual. El panorama europeo es bastante distinto. Analizando los referendos realizados en 12 países occidentales (10 europeos) en los últimos 12 años - y excluyendo el nivel cantonal suizo y el nivel local por su elevado número- se constata la realización de casi 200 referendos. No se observa, en cambio, ninguna correlación entre el grado de descentralización de un país y el uso de referendos. Resultan notorios los 28 casos de referendos relacionados con decisiones secesionistas, soberanía o sobre cambios importantes en la división territorial de poderes: representan un 34% de las consultas con "impacto institucional" de este periodo. ...
FERRAN REQUEJO, catedrático de Ciencia Política en la UPF y autor de ´Las democracias´ (Ariel 2008). ferran. requejo@ upf. edu
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
2:43 PM
0
comments
Labels: Democracia Direta, ESPAÑA, Referendo
BERMUDA: Access to information benefits democracy
The following recent article from Bermuda coinciding with International Right to Know Day supports the passing of PATI legislation in Bermuda and highlights the need for free public access to information in order to ensure transparency and accountability in representative government and as a prerequisite for citizen participation in governance. - Editor
How Freedom of Information benefits democracy
Published: September 27. 2008 09:16AM
Source: http://www.royalgazette.com/siftology.royalgazette/Article/article.jsp?articleId=7d89db230030002§ionId=60
With PATI legislation Bermuda would be seen internationally as a safer place to work, live and trade
Tomorrow is International Right to Know Day, established in 2002 to mark the founding on September 28 of the global Freedom of Information Advocates Network.
It aims to raise awareness of every individual's right of access to government-held information, the right to know how elected officials are exercising power and how taxpayers' money is being spent.
Through its A Right to Know – Giving People Power campaign,The Royal Gazette is calling on the Government to speedily introduce its Public Access to Information (PATI) law.
This article was written for this newspaper by James M. Ferguson, of the Access to Information Programme Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative.
The right to information, a human right first recognised by the United Nations in Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, is a right that plays a crucial role in ensuring that citizens are better informed about both the people they are electing and the activities undertaken by them while in government.
The underlying foundation of the democratic tradition rests on the premise of an informed electorate that is able to hold its government accountable for the policies and decisions it makes. To retain legitimacy and respect, elected representatives must be accountable to the public by openly disclosing information about the activities they undertake with public funds.
Since the UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948, human rights have been further developed and codified in international law by individual UN treaties. One of the core human rights treaties is the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), under which Article 19 concerns the right to access information: a right which gives practical meaning to the principles of participatory democracy. Adherence to the standards rooted in these core international human rights treaties is the benchmark by which the international community may judge the legitimacy of a government.
Bermuda accordingly has an opportunity to increase its legitimacy in the international community through the introduction of a functioning Public Access to Information (PATI) regime. In addition to informing the electorate generally, a functioning PATI regime will also be a means the following specific ends:
• First, it will operate as an effective anti-corruption tool, increasing transparency by opening up government decision-making processes to public scrutiny. In 2004, of the ten countries scoring worst in Transparency International's annual Corruption Perceptions Index, only one had a functioning access to information regime. In contrast, of the ten countries perceived to be the best in terms of corruption, no fewer than eight had effective legislation enabling the public to see government files.
• Second, it will support participatory development. Much of the failure of development strategies is attributable to their being designed and implemented in a closed environment: one that is absent of participation by the governed.If governments are obligated to provide information, the governed can be empowered to more holistically determine their own development by assessing for themselves the merits of competing development strategies.
•Third, it will provide support to economic development and the market-friendly, good governance principles of transparency and accountability. Markets, like governments, do not function well in secrecy, and openness encourages a political and economic environment more conducive to the free market tenets of 'perfect information' and 'perfect competition'. A right to information ensures that information does not become commodified solely for the benefit of, in political terms, the bureaucracy; in economic terms, the increased flow of information empowers consumers to choose better products, and the market rewards those making the best products with higher sales. Increased information flow thus encourages greater investor confidence, resulting in stronger growth.
A functioning PATI regime will empower Bermudians to observe the standards rooted in the core human rights treaties. As an example, Article 13 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) creates a right to public education, the provision of which is binding upon signatories to the Convention. PATI legislation, by requiring government-run education institutions to provide parents and citizens access to information about schools, will effectively promote increased transparency and accountability in the education system and help satisfy international obligations under the ICESCR.
As another example, Article 13(1) of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) states, "the child shall have the right to freedom of expression; this right shall include freedom to seek, receive and impart information and ideas of all kinds, regardless of frontiers, either orally, in writing or in print, in the form of art, or through any other media of the child's choice." There exists an international consensus recognising the crucial significance of the right of access to information for children for realising their rights.
A well-drafted PATI law will also protect officials who wrongfully, but in good faith, disclose information under the Act. Officials responsible may legitimately be concerned that wrong decisions on their parts could result in action being taken against them. International experience demonstrates that a provision protecting government officials and employees is essential in order to foster a culture of openness and guard against this possibility.
The introduction of PATI legislation may cause temporary tension within branches of the government concerned with issues such as national security and energy; however, in almost all cases, it is easier to achieve sustainability on such issues in countries that are democratic and respect the rule of law. While there may be short-term challenges to reconcile, the long-term benefits in promoting human rights, democracy and good governance are clear.
The promotion of human rights, democracy, and good governance, is tangibly in the best interests of Bermuda. By adopting PATI legislation, Bermuda will be seen in the international community as a safer place in which to work, live, trade with or visit. Bermuda will also be seen as a country more likely to settle disputes peacefully and as one respecting international legal commitments: whether on human rights, security matters, economic issues, or the environment.
PATI legislation will harmonise the conflicting interests of a functioning democracy with interests of the efficient operations of government, the optimum use of limited resources, and the preservation of confidentiality of sensitive information. Countries which are truly democratic respect the rights of citizens and observe the rule of law both at home and abroad. This involves a process of decision making that respects a plurality of opinion, provides a framework for non-violent change, and manages conflict peacefully, based on equal opportunity to participate in the political process. A true democracy is a system of government in which individuals have the opportunity to fully realise their human rights.
James M. Ferguson is part of the Access to Information Programme of the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI), an international, independent, non-governmental organisation founded in 1987, with offices in India, Ghana and the United Kingdom, whose objectives are to promote awareness of and adherence to international human rights obligations for the practical realisation of human rights in Commonwealth countries.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
2:35 PM
1 comments
Labels: BERMUDA, CARIBBEAN, Freedom of Information Advocates Network, Human Rights, Participatory Democracy
Thursday, October 9, 2008
REPUBLICA DOMINICANA: Democracia Directa en la Nueva Constitución
En el proyecto de Constitución se abre paso a la regulación del cabildeo ante las instituciones públicas
José Carlos Nazario
jueves, 25 de septiembre de 2008
En días pasados el Presidente de la República presentó el Proyecto de Reforma Constitucional que, fruto de las consultas en diversos sectores, preparó el grupo de juristas que fuera convocado por el Ejecutivo para los fines. Sin entrar en discusiones sobre el mecanismo de modificación, nos gustaría tratar algunos aspectos.
En dicho proyecto, como hemos podido comprobar, se establecen principios que podrían dar espacio a una interesante e importantísima apertura del Estado hacia la participación social y ciudadana. En tal sentido hemos querido señalar algunos puntos del articulado que representan un claro avance en la materia.
Según establece el artículo 2 de la nueva propuesta constitucional, “el pueblo ejerce la soberanía por medio de sus representantes o en forma directa (…)” Hablamos, pues, de la superación del mito del Estado-padre/protector.
En el artículo 6 se reconoce a la República Dominicana como un Estado Social y Democrático de Derecho, esta cuestión, tocada anteriormente por nosotros y anunciada por el Presidente Fernández, constituye una llave para la creación de nuevos mecanismos de democracia directa que nos lleven al perfeccionamiento social de la organización jurídico-política de la nación.
Yendo más lejos, la comisión de juristas propone, en el numeral 3ro del artículo 20, sobre los derechos de las ciudadanas y los ciudadanos, el derecho a la “iniciativa congresional y municipal”, así como la formulación de “peticiones a los poderes públicos para solicitar medidas de interés público”. Ambos puntos pueden constituirse, sin duda, en una apertura hacia la gestión pública de intereses, el denominado lobbying, como mecanismo de participación política de la ciudadanía.
Por último los artículos 82 y 83 completan la alusión constitucional a la temática, postulando que dicha iniciativa legislativa se ejerce mediante la participación de no menos del 2% de los inscritos en el registro de electores y deja abierta la opción a una ley especial que establezca el procedimiento para la propuesta. De igual forma se estipula que quien ejerza dicha iniciativa tendrá derecho a sostener su propuesta ante la otra Cámara.
Con este articulado se abre paso, en la nueva Constitución, a la, tantas veces invocada, regulación del cabildeo ante las instituciones públicas. El famoso lobbying (gestión de intereses privados ante instituciones públicas), satanizado con intenciones non gratas por muchos promotores del arcaísmo estatal, debe ser limitado y diferenciado del tráfico de influencias. Su control daría paso al necesario proceso de empoderamiento ciudadano, que vendría a potenciar los cambios que por tanto tiempo hemos esperado de los políticos y que sin duda son responsabilidad exclusiva de nosotros, los ciudadanos.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
11:06 AM
0
comments
Labels: Democracia Directa, REPUBLICA DOMINICANA
Wednesday, October 8, 2008
GHANA: Non-Partisan Committee to Promote Participatory Democracy
Two articles about a newly formed local non-partisan oversight council in Ghana which has as a stated aim the promotion of participatory democracy. - Editor
APRM oversight committee inaugurated in Nkoranza
Source: http://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/regional/artikel.php?ID=151048
Donkro Nkwanta (B/A) Oct. 3 GNA - Mr Paul Baffoe-Ansah, Chairman of the Oversight Committee of the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM) Governing Council in Nkoranza South District in Brong Ahafo has noted that the under-development of many African countries was due to the slave trade that took away energetic and reproductive youth to work in foreign lands. He called on African leaders to unite to enable them to come out with better ideas, policies and measures that would enhance the development of their countries. Mr Baffoe-Ansah, who is the Secretary of Nkoranza South branch of Ghana National Association of Teachers (GNAT), was addressing chiefs and people of Donkro Nkwanta at the inauguration of the oversight committee in the district. Other executives of the committee are the Reverend Emmanuel Osei, Vice Chairman, Miss Agartha Osei, Secretary and Mr Kwame Osei, Financial Secretary.
The rest are Miss Margaret Ankomah Mansah, Nana Amah Pokuaa, Mr Kwadwo Ansah, Miss Grace Baffoe and Mr Daniel Ohene Djan. Mr Baffoe-Ansah expressed regret about how coups d'etats and poor leadership had rendered some African countries unstable and advised Ghanaians not to allow partisan politics to divide the nation and stall its development. He explained that the APRM was a non-partisan body formed in the various communities to assist in promoting participatory democracy among the people so they could participate in the decision-making process. The District Chairman urged the Ghanaian leadership to let the welfare of the people and the country's development be a priority and to initiate policies that would help improve the living standards of the people.
Mr Baffoe-Ansah called for effective collaboration among political parties, traditional and religious authorities in organizing the people to contribute their quota towards national development. Mr Yaw Effah-Manu, District Director of National Commission for Civic Education, appealed to the nation's leadership to ensure that poverty, diseases and hunger were eradicated so the people could live comfortably. He urged the people to support the committee to achieve its target of promoting democracy in the country. Farmers at the forum appealed to the government to construct feeder roads to help them to convey their produce to marketing centres.
________________________________________________________________________________
KINTAMPO SOUTH:
MMDA’s cautioned
Source: http://www.ghanadistricts.com/news/?read=14961&PHPSESSID=7802d91b2e127ac7ccf221177d8418eb
The Chairman of the Governing Council of the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM), Reverend Professor S.K. Adjepong, has cautioned Municipal and District assemblies against interfering in the activities of oversight committees of the council since they do not belong to any political party.
He was speaking at the inauguration of oversight committees for Kintampo North, Kintampo South and Nkoranza North districts at Kintampo.
“The committees are independent bodies challenged with the responsibility to find from the people their views about the governance of the nation, as stakeholders in national development”, he said.
The Rev Professor Adjepong explained that the APRM was aimed at monitoring and tracking the programmes of some African governments who are expected to give account of their stewardship to their people at a given period to enhance participatory democracy.
He urged members of the oversight committees to be good role models but to guard against partisan politicking, be loyal and submissive to win the support of the people.
A member of the governing council, Professor S.K.B. Asante, commended the committee members for offering to take up the voluntary but Herculean task to serve the state, saying they were establishing legacies as responsible citizens.
GNA
[2008-05-12 02:24:38]
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
9:15 AM
0
comments
Labels: AFRICA, Community Councils, GHANA, Participatory Democracy
ARGENTINA: Presupuesto Participativo en Rafaela
Rafaela - Se pone en marcha Presupuesto Ciudadano de Gestión Participativa
El trabajo conjunto de varias secretarías de la Municipalidad de Rafaela posibilita la implementación del Presupuesto Ciudadano de Gestión Participativa para el año 2009.
Un poco de historia
A lo largo de la historia el concepto de presupuesto ciudadano ha evolucionado considerablemente, hasta convertirse en una buena práctica dentro de la caja de herramientas de un gobierno que le da vital importancia a la participación de vecinos e instituciones, al momento de definir el destino de una parte de los fondos públicos.
Las definiciones describen al Presupuesto Ciudadano de Gestión Participativa como una forma de elaborar el presupuesto en donde vecinos y municipio trabajan en conjunto para decidir el destino de una parte de los fondos públicos. La ordenanza municipal N° 4.133, sancionada el 06/12/07, contempla:
“Art. 9º) El Departamento Ejecutivo Municipal ejecutará entre el cinco por ciento (5%) y el diez por ciento (10%) de su Presupuesto total anual, afectando el mismo a gastos cuya ejecución requiera de la participación de las instituciones representativas de la sociedad civil, a fin de definir en forma conjunta con el Municipio el destino de esos fondos.”
Con la implementación de herramientas presupuestarias como la presente se fortalecen muchos de los objetivos de la democracia , en especial, en lo referido a la asignación de los recursos públicos hacia aquellas necesidades más específicas de los barrios de la cuidad, la posibilidad de que cualquier individuo pueda participar (independientemente de su pertenencia a una institución) combina democracia participativa y representativa, implica deliberación (no sólo consulta) y garantiza el control de las gestión, entre otros.
El caso Rafaela
Existe una gran variedad de modalidades mediante las cuales es posible implementar el presupuesto ciudadano. En el caso de nuestra ciudad, el gobierno local posee desde hace más de una década, mecanismos para discutir con las instituciones la asignación de fondos específicos, como el caso de las Comisiones Municipales Asesoras de Entidades de Bien Público, de Discapacitados, de Cultura y de Deportes, así como los fondos destinados al SAMCO, fondos para becas, de asistencia escolar (Fondo de Asistencia Escolar, FAE), el Fondo de Fortalecimiento Institucional, y aquellos destinados al ITEC (Instituto Tecnológico de Rafaela).
Actualmente se encuentra en marcha un mecanismo alternativo que involucra la participación de los vecinos en la elección de obras prioritarias para su barrio, que comenzó con un proceso de rendición de cuentas. Hacia fines del año 2007, la Secretaría de Desarrollo Social y la Subsecretaría de Integración Comunitaria del municipio organizaron talleres con los representantes vecinales de los barrios de la ciudad. En los mismos, los vecinalistas elaboraron solicitudes al gobierno municipal respecto a cuestiones específicas como arreglos en la sede, realización de talleres para niños, reparación de calles, etc.
En el mes de julio se realizó una reunión introductoria donde se manifestó la intención gubernamental de establecer un esquema de discusión que contempla la participación de la ciudadanía el que se denomina Presupuesto Ciudadano de Gestión Participativa. Luego de este primer encuentro, se convocó nuevamente a los vecinalistas para en grupos de dos o tres barrios, vinculados en base a determinados criterios como ubicación geográfica, problemáticas comunes, rasgos identitarios; abordar las problemáticas particulares y debatir la manera más adecuada de avanzar en conjunto con este proyecto.
Los encuentros persiguieron, fundamentalmente, dos objetivos:
Retomar los pedidos realizados en los talleres del año anterior generando una devolución a dichas demandas en función de la información recopilada. Explicar nuevamente el proyecto y avanzar en los requerimientos específicos de cada barrio. Fue así como se escucharon las demandas y problemáticas específicas de cada barrio, y se explicó claramente qué tipo de reclamos podían constituirse como opciones de las obras y/o actividades del presupuesto ciudadano 2009. En cada reunión se invitó a participar a todos los miembros de la comisión vecinal, como representantes legítimos de los vecinos de la ciudad. Respecto al municipio participaron de las reuniones funcionarios de las distintas secretarías y subsecretarías.
Este esquema de reuniones permitió un diálogo frontal entre funcionarios y vecinalistas, que avanzaron en el tratamiento de cuestiones específicas de los barrios en base a una idea de construcción colectiva de la ciudad.
Prensa Municipalidad de Rafaela
Enviado el Viernes, 26 septiembre a las 20:05:42
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
8:05 AM
0
comments
Labels: ARGENTINA, Presupuesto Participativo
Monday, October 6, 2008
PARAGUAY: Vecinalistas Piden Apoyo a la Ley de Participación Ciudadana
Vecinalistas pideron gobierno apoyo a ley de participación ciudadana.
Por medio de una carta enviada al mandatario Fernando Lugo, la Federación de Entidades Vecinalistas del Paraguay envió un informe sobre los alcances que tendrá la referida ley que está en estudio en el Parlamento Nacional. Por otro lado, solicitó una audiencia para debatir sobre proyectos que beneficien a las comunidades de todo el país.
EXCELENTÍSIMO
DON FERNANDO LUGO
PRESIDENTE DE LA REPÚBLICA DEL PARAGUAY
PALACIO DE LÓPEZ
De nuestra distinguida consideración:
Con relación al Eje Temático de “Participación Ciudadana en las políticas públicas” nos dirigimos a V. E. a objeto de hacer presente un resumen de "Resultados de los Procesos de Discusión y Análisis de Propuestas entre Organizaciones de la Sociedad Civil e Instituciones del Gobierno Nacional", emergentes de reuniones y talleres semanales realizados en los meses de julio, agosto y septiembre del corriente año, con activo protagonismo de representantes de instituciones del Gobierno, ONGs y organizaciones sociales vinculadas a la gestión social pluralista e incluyente.
Como no escapa al conocimiento de V. E., el proceso de construcción de una ciudadanía activa y responsable en el marco de la autonomía de las organizaciones, debe superar las limitadas visiones localistas y las naturales divergencias políticas, partidarias o sectoriales, hacia una convergencia más amplia y generosa que permitan "mirar el bosque y no solamente el árbol". Ese afán nos motiva como ciudadanos a asumir un rol genuino de protagonistas y promotores de una Participación constante, cooperando en el diseño de Políticas de Estado eficaces y programas públicos eficientes, en la ruta hacia el Bien Común. Comprometidos también
a seguir supliendo la carencia de recursos con la voluntad y el empeño, para contribuir con esfuerzo constante a mejorar la calidad de vida de todos los paraguayos, sin exclusiones.
La Democracia Participativa está consagrada en el Artículo Primero de la Constitución Nacional que dispone: "la República del Paraguay adopta para su gobierno la democracia representativa, participativa y pluralista, fundada en el reconocimiento de la dignidad humana". La sociedad civil organizada y la creciente madurez ciudadana, son herramientas válidas para una cooperación sostenida a la Gestión Pública del Gobierno Nacional en el área Social, legitimando las propuestas así pensadas y planificadas "desde abajo y desde adentro", con la activa cooperación de la población afectada.
En zonas urbanas y rurales, que los gobiernos locales tengan desempeño y logros útiles al desarrollo es interés de la ciudadanía y deseo de las comunidades. Ello obliga a las OSCs a enfocar una participación más directa y constante también con gobiernos departamentales y municipales en las etapas de diseño, planeamiento, ejecución y evaluación (contraloría ciudadana) de la gestión pública. La Ley de Participación Ciudadana en estudio en el Congreso Nacional (aprobada "en general" por la HCD) y el estudio de otras sobre Transparencia y Acceso a la Información e Iniciativas Populares, podrán acrecentar la Participación consolidando en el país el aún incipiente Capital Social.
Adjuntamos a la presente materiales relativos a la nómina de entidades y organizaciones participantes en esta Primera Etapa de los trabajos (Anexo 1); conclusiones del trabajo inter-institucional completado el pasado 8 de septiembre de
2008 (Anexo 2, Trifoliar) así como una Presentación del Resumen (Power Point) en formatos impreso (Anexo 3) y digital (Anexo 4). El marco conceptual referido y las propuestas de trabajo también fueron discutidos, consensuados y acordados en talleres inster institucionales realizados en un marco muy dinámico y participativo.
Nos permitimos solicitar a V. E. una Audiencia con el Gabinete Social, en la brevedad posible, a fin de presentar estas Conclusiones correspondientes a la Etapa 1 (30 días, 15/09/08); y así coordinar avances para las siguientes faces de trabajo a corto, mediano y largo plazo. Ello permitirá a este equipo interinstitucional exponer los productos y servicios logrados en la Etapa 2, en una siguiente Evaluación (60 días, hasta el 15/11/08).
Saludamos a V. E. con nuestra distinguida consideración
Fuente: jakueke.com
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
12:30 PM
1 comments
Labels: Democracia Participativa, PARAGUAY
Saturday, October 4, 2008
VENEZUELA: Fact Check - Human Rights Abuse Claims are False

Contrary to the recent report issued by Human Rights Watch in an apparent attempt to promulgate and disseminate a view of Venezuela that is purposely false and misleading in order to feed the fires of anti-Chavez sentiment and portray him as an authoritarian dictator, participatory democracy is thriving in Venezuela and human rights have improved since Chavez was first elected. While of course human rights abuses do occur in Venezuela today, they do not emanate from and are not sanctioned by the government of Hugo Chavez. They can generally be attributed to one of two sources:
- Those perpetrated by local police and security forces geographically removed from the center of government in Caracas. These are not politically motivated abuses, and are an unfortunate leftover from the patterns of behavior generated in pre-Chavez years when security forces were trained by the U.S. intelligence services in the methods of brutality and summary justice. These abuses have been on the wane because of efforts of the Chavez government to stop them and bring the perpetrators to justice, and of course the termination of training programs provided by or influenced by U.S. intelligence operations.
- Those perpetrated by members of the opposition inciting violence in an attempt to destabilize the country and disrupt the democratic process. These include politically motivated killings by security forces aligned with the opposition.
- "There were no reports that the government or its agents committed any politically motivated killings; however, security forces committed unlawful killings, including summary executions of criminal suspects. In the 12 months prior to September, the human rights nongovernmental organization (NGO) Venezuelan Program of Action and Education in Human Rights (PROVEA) reported 51 deaths resulting from mistreatment while in custody."
- "There were no substantiated reports of politically motivated disappearances."
Shame on Human Rights Watch for taking part in this misinformation campaign against a democratically elected government in Venezuela that is bringing participatory democracy and equality to a nation that has traditionally known only injustice, exploitation, and oligarchical rule. See our previous posts on Venezuela to learn more about participatory democracy in that country. - Editor
Venezuela: Human Rights Watch versus democracy
The US-based NGO Human Rights Watch has issued a new report on Venezuela. The report blatantly distorts the truth in order to promote the regime-change agenda of the United States administration.
Source: http://21stcenturysocialism.com/article/venezuela_human_rights_watch_versus_democracy_01734.htmll
On Sept 18th 2008, Human Rights Watch (HRW) released a report entitled 'Venezuela: Rights Suffer Under Chavez'. The report has been characterised by the Venezuelan government as biased and inaccurate.
The HRW report comes in the wake of an intensification of attacks on Venezuela by various branches of the US administration. These include:
• the re-establishment of the Fourth Fleet – previously decommissioned in 1952, the Fourth Fleet is reportedly made up of 25 warships, deployed around South America; and about which, several Latin American countries, Brazil, Argentina and Venezuela, amongst them, have expressed deep concerns;
• John Walters, the US drug Czar, has accused Venezuela of inaction in the war on drugs;
• the US State Department recently discussed the possibility of adding Venezuela to the list of nations that sponsor terrorism;
• the allegation that the Venezuelan government was behind the suitcase stuffed with US$800,000 brought into Argentina by Venezuelan-American citizen, Antonini Wilson, but, which, in reality, was denounced by Chavez and Argentine President Cristina Fernandez, as a dirty operation, about which nothing has been conclusively demonstrated, but which has become the focus of intense media attention. Despite repeated requests by both Argentina and Venezuela, US authorities have refused to extradite Antonini to face questions;
• sanctions by the US Treasury of several Venezuelan officials over unproven allegations that they aided the Revolutionary Armed Forces (FARC) of Colombia.
Most recently, following the expulsion of the US Ambassador from Bolivia over his relations with right wing extremists, Venezuela expelled its US Ambassador in solidarity, and the US responded by expelling the Venezuelan Ambassador from the USA.
On 10th September 2008, a plot to assassinate President Chavez and carry out a military coup was exposed. The plot was led by high level retired and serving military officers.
This is the context, one of of acute tensions between Venezuela and the US, for the publication on 18th September of the Human Rights Watch report on Venezuela. Its key theme, as outlined by José Miguel Vivanco, Americas director at HRW, is as follows:
“Ten years ago, Chávez promoted a new constitution that could have significantly improved human rights in Venezuela. But rather than advancing rights protections, his government has since moved in the opposite direction, sacrificing basic guarantees in pursuit of its own political agenda.”
The 230-page Report makes the charge that “Discrimination on political grounds has been a defining feature of the Chavez presidency.” Although Venezuela under President Chavez is by no means perfect, it bears no relation to the country depicted in HRW’s 2008 Report.
The key allegation, that discrimination on political grounds has been a defining feature of the Chavez presidency, looks absurd when it is understood that the civil service remains largely full of supporters of the old regime, some of whom have allegedly engaged in criminal actions, such as the destruction of key operational facilities of the national oil company PDVSA during the oil lock-out that brought the country’s economy to near collapse.
The lock-out took place almost immediately after the short-lived overthrow of President Chavez in a military coup in April 2002. The coup was backed by the military high command, the main private media, the national employers’ organisation and the old discredited trade union federation CTV.
Following the coup, there was a campaign to oust Chavez through a recall referendum in 2004. When that failed, the opposition boycotted the 2005 parliamentary election in order to try to question the legitimacy of the government. Throughout these tense events, opposition politicians and private media talked openly of violently overthrowing the government and adopted an intensely confrontational attitude.
The recently revealed plot for another coup attempt and plans to assassinate President Chavez, just before regional and local elections in November, are in line with the stance taken by the opposition at crucial moments.
Expanding democracy
Contrary to HRW’s allegations that the Venezuelan government practices ‘political discrimination’ against the opposition, the government’s attitude to the opposition’s persistent efforts to use violent and unconstitutional means to overthrow it, has been one of tolerance and magnanimity. Last year, President Chávez pardoned political opponents who backed the failed 2002 coup against his democratically-elected government. “It’s a matter of turning the page,” Chávez said. "We want there to be a strong ideological and political debate - but in peace.”
In this spirit, the government has often welcomed input from the opposition, for example, inviting the leaders of student protests to address the National Assembly. Not a common occurrence anywhere else in the world.
All political parties in Venezuela operate without any constraints. The majority of these parties are in the opposition; their difficulty is that they do not enjoy the high levels of support of the fewer pro-government political parties.
Opposition parties in Venezuela can and do organise public meetings, rallies, demonstrations, street marches; their spokespersons speak regularly on TV and radio – and they never moderate their language, their criticism, or their opposition to the government. They stand candidates for elections, hold national party events, issue proclamations, statements, hold press conferences, publish books, pamphlets, disseminate anti-government propaganda – in the streets and through the media, without any governmental sanctions whatsoever.
The great majority of private newspapers and television stations in the country support the Opposition and they face no restrictions other than the normal ones that exist in any democratic country, such as those governing libel and defamation. No Venezuelan newspaper has ever been subjected to any censorship by the Chavez administration. There are no political prisoners of any kind in Venezuela.
With regard to the judiciary, contrary to the 2008 HRW report’s contention, under Chavez the independence and probity of the judiciary has been significantly strengthened by dealing with the corruption with which it was previously riddled. HRW’s own 2004 report recognized this:
“When President Chávez became president in 1999, he inherited a judiciary that had been plagued for years by influence-peddling, political interference, and, above all, corruption...In terms of public credibility, the system was bankrupt.”
At the same time, all democratic institutions have been strengthened in Venezuela, exemplified by the internationally verified efficiency and scrupulous fairness of the National Electoral Council, which has had no hesitation in upholding electoral results unfavourable to the government such as the defeat of the 2007 constitutional referendum – a result accepted immediately by President Chavez and his government.
HRW’s assertion that the Venezuelan media balance is shifting in favour of Chavez is misleading. In fact, the opposition media enjoy unrestricted freedom but they are increasingly seen as grossly biased and as having lost the political argument. The reality remains that the private media, which largely supports the opposition, controls the largest share of the airwaves, and there are no major pro-government national daily newspapers.
HRW’s allegation that the government “has sought to remake the country’s labor movement in ways that violate basic principles of freedom of association,” also bears no relation to reality.
There are six national trade union federations in Venezuela (CTV, CUTV, UNT, CODESA, CGT, and CST), all of which function with total freedom and without the kind of draconian anti-trade union legislation which disfigures the USA and many of its allies.
Industrial relations are evolving positively. Furthermore, the level of trade union membership is rising – before Chávez came to office in 1999, 11% of workers were in unions; the figure now is estimated to be over 20%. Thus, HRW’s allegation that the government violates basic principles of union association is not borne out by the facts.
The charge of the HRW 2008 report that the Chávez government has an “aggressively adversarial approach to local rights advocates and civil society organizations” is equally false. With varying degrees of success, the government has been empowering millions of hitherto excluded people through an array of social organizations, such as – tens of thousands of - communal councils, which aim to democratize local government.
There are also 200,000 cooperatives, women’s organizations, indigenous organizations, Afro-descendants organizations, organizations of gays and lesbians, and so forth. The numbers of these organizations have mushroomed because their rights have, for the first time ever, been either enshrined in the 1999 constitution or are being actively promoted and the government has been keen to assist them.
Additionally, as part of the implementation of the principles of participatory democracy enshrined in the 1999 Constitution, the government has made successful efforts to enfranchise ever larger layers of the traditionally excluded.
In terms of the traditional electoral process, the number of registered voters has increased phenomenonally. When Chávez was first elected President in 1998 the number of registered voters was 11,013,020. This has increased to 16,109,664 (a staggering 60% increase) by the time of the 2007 Constitutional Referendum.
At the same time, Venezuela has held more internationally recognized democratic elections than virtually any other country in the world in the decade Chávez has been in office.
To argue, as does the HRW, that this situation corresponds in any way to stifling civil society is to deny reality.
US-funded opposition
The government, however, has had serious concerns about illegal activity by a relatively small number of NGO-type bodies funded by the USA, which engage in campaigns to subvert the constitutional order. The US funded SUMATE ‘NGO’, for example, centralized the collection of signatures to unseat Chavez in 2004, and its leader, Corina Machado, endorsed the 2002 coup.
The publicly acknowledged funding of such so-called NGOs comes from US government sources including the infamous National Endowment for Democracy, USAID, the International Republican Institute (IRI), the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs, the American Centre for International Labour Solidarity and the Centre for International Private Enterprise. The government of Venezuela charges that these organisations are channels for the covert funding of opposition groups to seek to undermine democratic institutions and the elected government.
This charge is amply confirmed by international experience. One example illustrates this. On hearing of the ousting of Chávez in April 2002, International Republican Institute President, George A. Folsom, issued the following statement:
“Last night, led by every sector of civil society, the Venezuelan people rose up to defend democracy in their country. Venezuelans were provoked into action as a result of systematic repression by the Government of Hugo Chavez. Several hundred thousand people filled the streets of Caracas to demand the resignation of Lt. Col. Chavez.”
The chairman of the IRI since 1993 has been the current Republican presidential candidate John McCain, who has made no bones about his intense antagonism to progressive governments in Latin America, especially, Chavez. His campaign website even featured an online petition calling for support in his quest to “stop the dictators of Latin America.” The petition called for the removal of Chávez “in the name of democracy and freedom throughout our hemisphere.” Although the petition was taken down, it is an indication of his thinking, as leader of this NGO funder and a possible future president of the USA.
In a similar vein, several months after the failed 2002 coup, the US State Dept established an Office of Transition Initiatives (OTI) in Caracas, with money from USAID and which operates out of the US Embassy with, among other stated objectives: “to provide fast, flexible, short-term assistance targeted at key transition needs.” ‘Transition’ has to be seen in the context of the US administration’s doctrine of its right to seek to externally promote ‘regime change’ in countries which it perceives as pursuing policies against the interests of the sections of the US it represents.
The Chávez government has been expanding democracy and social progress to unprecedented levels. And in truth, there is no serious evidence of any systematic effort or policy aimed at attacking human rights; in fact, all evidence points in the opposite direction. Therefore, it is difficult not to conclude that HRW’s 2008 report, as on previous occasions, does not have the purpose of constructive criticism of shortcomings or possible flaws in the process of social progress and democratization underway in Venezuela – which would be welcome – but that it distorts reality to depict a country on the verge of becoming a nasty dictatorship.
The imbalance in the HRW report is evident in that, for example, it does not even mention the substantial progress that has been made in improving the human rights of the immense majority of the population by such means as:
• the reduction of poverty (by 34%);
• the eradication of illiteracy;
• the expansion of education from 6 million people participating in education in 1998 to more than 12 million in 2008;
• the access to free health care increased to the great majority of the population, about 20 million people, by 2008;
• the provision of subsidized food benefiting 12-14 million people in 2008;
• the reduction in unemployment to historic low levels of around 7% in
2008;
• the promotion of a far greater role of women in society and the economy; and
• the dramatic increase in social spending that has taken place in Venezuela since the election of Chavez.
The unbalanced and plain misleading character of HRW’s reports on Venezuela has been consistent and has coincided uncannily with the run-up to important electoral contests such as the forthcoming November elections this year. It issued a communiqué on Venezuela with similar unsubstantiated themes in June 2004, just two months before the recall referendum against Chavez. In October 2007, it published a statement expressing similar preoccupations just two months before the constitutional referendum. And HRW published its 2008 report on 18th September, just two months away from regional and local authority elections in Venezuela in November 2008.
All these reports have echoed US anti-Chavez propaganda: ‘a dictatorship is in the making in Venezuela’. Back in June, John McCain said in a speech to the Florida Association of Broadcasters: “Hugo Chavez has used the cloak of electoral legitimacy to establish a one party dictatorship in Venezuela.”
The question presents itself: who stands to gain from Human Rights Watch activity in Venezuela – the population of the country or the Washington administration seeking to undermine an elected government seen as breaking free of its traditional economic and political domination?
Dr Francisco Domínguez is head of the Centre for Brazilian and Latin American Studies at Middlesex University, UK.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
2:07 PM
0
comments
Labels: Human Rights, LATIN AMERICA, Participatory Democracy, Venezuela
Thursday, October 2, 2008
GUATEMALA: Foro Tocará el Tema de la La Democracia Directa
Foro social en Guatemala
La Usac será la sede.
Por: Helmer Velásquez
Fuente: http://www.elperiodico.com.gt/es/20080925/opinion/72082
Convocada por tercera ocasión, la cumbre social del hemisferio congregará alrededor de 6 mil representantes de redes sociales, populares y pueblos originarios de las américas y el mundo, del 7 al 12 de octubre, bajo el alero de la Universidad de San Carlos, cuya Ciudad Universitaria será sede del evento. ¿Por qué es importante este evento para el movimiento social guatemalteco? El proceso de construcción de la cumbre está llamado a constituirse en el motor de la refundación de la propia alianza social. Debe ser el acicate para la forja de nuevos y cualitativos niveles de unidad.
Revitalización de la agenda del movimiento, reconstrucción de vasos comunicantes e impulso a nuevos y beligerantes actores, dentro de los cuales las comunidades organizadas en defensa de sus recursos naturales y territorio adquieren singular relevancia. Bajo estas premisas, el movimiento social guatemalteco, –sigo acá los comentarios de Edwin Ortega y Jeanina Ponce, personeros del foro– aspira a renovada unidad, agenda política común y vínculos estrechos con los procesos de integración de los pueblos. La importancia del foro se refleja en los temas de agenda dentro de los que aparecen: Nuevos roles de los Estados. Democracia directa, social y popular. Pueblos originarios, resistencia y lucha por el territorio. Mercantilización de la vida, instrumentos de la apertura comercial versus comercio con justicia. Crisis e inequitativo acceso a los alimentos.
Militarización de nuestras sociedades. Neoliberalismo y post-neoliberalismo. Desarrollo endógeno.
Socialismo en el siglo XXI. Cambio climático. Minería. Reforma Agraria. Equidad de género y de pueblos. Entre otros sensibles problemas a debatir. Este festival de la amistad y la solidaridad entre los pueblos, es excelente oportunidad para pensadores, dirigentes y activistas sociales nacionales, para el intercambio de ideas, experiencias y propuestas con dirigentes internacionales de amplia experiencia. Una innegable oportunidad para escuchar a los nuevos pensadores latinoamericanos.
Cierra el III Foro Social Américas con una caminata por las calles de la ciudad de Guatemala, en conmemoración del Día de la Resistencia Indígena, Negra y Popular, desarrollo rural y reforma agraria, demandas centrales de la organización campesina e indígena guatemalteca, quienes estarán presentes a lo largo del recorrido. La Guatemala social estará de nuevo al centro de la mirada continental: hospitalaria, solidaria y políticamente responsable.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
11:48 AM
0
comments
Labels: Democracia Directa, GUATEMALA
PERU: Mining Referendum in Piura
Written by Jennifer Moore
Tuesday, 16 September 2008
One year ago today, a local vote was held concerning possible mining activity in three highland districts in northwestern Peru. The referendum drew thousands of peasant farmers, many of whom traveled for the best part of a day by horse, truck or on foot to mark their ballot “yes” or “no.”
“We are here to say ‘no’ to this mining project,” said one young woman from the El Carmen de la Frontera district, close to the northern border with Ecuador. “And we would like the government to respect the decisions that we are making here.”
“We are defending our water and land for our children and grandchildren,” she stated, speaking to a film crew from Guarango Cine y Video.
This week, people in the districts of Ayabaca, Pacaipampa and El Carmen de la Frontera are commemorating last year’s impressive results: about 60% of the electorate participated and 94.5% said “no.”
But one year later, the government of President Alan Garcia still refuses to recognize the results.
“There is no reason that this project shouldn’t go through,” said Garcia to members of the Zijin Mining Consortium during his trip to China in March.
Zijin is the major shareholder in Rio Blanco Copper S.A. (formerly Minera Majaz S.A.). UK-based Monterrico Metals also maintains an interest in the project that is hoped to reach production by 2011. It could be the start of a large scale mining district reaching across the Ecuadorian border.
Garcia’s statement, however, not only ignores last year’s decision but also dismisses reports from several national institutions that declare the project illegal and in violation of the project’s own environmental plan.
In the lead up to the vote, the Ombudsman’s Office reported that the project was illegal. They cited the company’s lack of the two-thirds approval from assemblies of the two campesino communities on whose land the copper and molybdenum mineral exploration activities would take place, as required by Peruvian law.
In early 2008, the Supervisory Body for Private Investments in Energy and Mines (OSINERGMIN) sanctioned the company for not meeting its environmental commitments to the Ministry of Energy and Mines.
But despite social and environmental red flags, the government has insisted “on radical neoliberal and centralizing policies inevitably [leading] to political polarization and the deepening of social conflicts,” comments Rafael Hoetmer from the Democracy and Global Transformation Program in Lima and one of about two dozen international observers who attended the Piura vote last year.
Dialogue broke down between the government and communities after it had just begun. In December 2007, Prime Minister Jorge del Castillo walked out from one of the first meetings with the Front for Sustainable Development on the Northern Border of Peru (FDSFNP) because they wanted the referendum results to be on the agenda.
But the government had already signaled that productive discussions would be difficult. It tried to boycott the referendum and have it declared illegal. It had also signed a stability agreement with the company and included the Rio Blanco Project in a proposed bill to congress designating it and nineteen other mining projects as national priorities. While the bill failed to pass, the conflict continued.
After Castillo walked out, the Front - which represents communities, social organizations and municipalities of Piura as well as potentially affected areas of the neighbouring department of Cajamarca - decided to reaffirm their decision opposing mining and favouring an agricultural-based economy.
In what they called “The March of Sacrifice,” community members walked for six days from the municipality of Ayabaca to the capital of Piura.
“We have been very clear,” Hoetmer wrote, quoting Magdiel Carrión, President of the Provincial Federation of Farmer Communities of Ayabaca (FEPROCCA), “We do not want mining in our communities. It contaminates the water, creates conflicts, and doesn’t even bring us sustainable development.”
“As communities we have our own development model based on farming, ecotourism and our social organization. We have the same rights as the people of Lima and all other Peruvians. Both Peruvian and international law recognises the democratic right of communities to decide their own future.”
As part of a broader effort to repress the mining opposition, government and company supporters have criminalized the struggle in Piura.
According to an August report published by the Peruvian Observatory of Mining Conflicts, around 300 people involved in mining conflicts in Piura are currently facing charges. In the most notable case, thirty-five people involved in the promotion or organization of last year’s referendum face allegations of various crimes, including terrorism. According to the Environmental Defender Law Centre (EDLC), the charges have been brought by a “shadowy organization” called the Front of Unity for the Campesino Community of Segunda y Cajas.
"Let’s make no mistake what’s going on here,” comments Lewis Gordon lawyer and director of EDLC, “it’s a politically motivated effort by those who are unhappy about the activities of the leaders and others trying to stop the mine or the mining activities.”
Peruvian critics allege that the Front, whose name refers to one of two peasant farmer communities whose land pertains to the Rio Blanco project, is receiving money from the company and is made up of known company supporters.
The accusations it made were presented as a set of newspaper clippings, which Gordon calls “vague” and “very troubling to the extent that they allege criminal acts, but don’t indicate that the 35 participated or are in anyway connected to those acts other than the fact that those people were part of the anti-mining opposition itself.”
A recent analysis carried out by a group of US and UK lawyers was presented to the Prosecutor responsible for the case and looked at a range of possible charges, including terrorism, based on the facts as they understand them. It concluded that the 35 could not be prosecuted under US or UK criminal law and that prosecuting the individuals based on the current facts would violate international human rights law. Peru has ratified a number of agreements, including the American Convention on Human Rights.
“The real threat of these efforts and the impact they potentially have is to deter people from exercising their rights and to deter a debate on matters of extreme public interest, where everyone should be able to express their views and let the battle of ideas and participation decide the issue, instead of just trying to stop one group from participating in that debate.”
Decreeing collective rights away
A broad array of new legislation passed from January to June 2008 also threatening a more inclusive process pertaining to development in Peru. President Garcia issued over one hundred decrees during this period for the purpose of implementing the new Free Trade Agreement with the US. “At least forty decrees concern issues related to peasant and native communities and natural resources,” reports the UK-based Peru Support Group (PSG).
In part these imply “that the 'prior agreement' of the landowner regarding how property will be used - for instance, for mining - is no longer necessary,” says the bulletin from PSG. “Companies…could develop activities by simply gaining approval of the Ministry for Energy and Mines (MINEM).”
“Peasant communities, or other owners, would therefore no longer decide the fate of their lands.”
In August, indigenous groups led a twelve-day strike in the Peruvian Northern Amazon in protest of these laws. Ulises Garcia observes that their demands “are effectively in defense of the right to consultation,” noting a relationship to the struggle taking place in Piura.
Garcia is the son of Godofredo Garcia Baca, who was assassinated shortly before the first local vote over mining took place in Tambogrande in 2002. Tambogrande is an agro-export area in the lowlands of Piura. He continues to support ecological networks that assisted in the more recent vote in the eastern highlands.
The Amazonian protests concluded when Peru’s Parliament repealed two laws that were, according to Pulsar News Service, seen to be “opening the door for privatization of ancestral territories.” Garcia calls it “a victory for this struggle.”
A peaceful and democratic solution
The conflict in Piura emerged in 2004 and had already led to the deaths of two area residents when the local vote took place. When the decision to call a local vote was taken, community members hoped that a democratic expression of local opinion could provide a peaceful solution.
But at the moment, Garcia says that the situation in Piura has deteriorated. “Both sides are desperate. There is no development and no peace.”
“The communities in particular,” he says, “are in urgent need of legal support.” In addition to the multitude of charges they are facing, communities have also sued the company for usurpation of their lands. But this case is moving along very slowly.
Tension is also rising in other parts of the region, as companies start to reassert their interest in gold mining in places like Tambogrande, where the 2002 vote resulted in 98% rejection of mining, with the participation of 75% of the electorate.
In fact, the Ombudsman’s Office reported in July that mining has contributed to a rising number of socio-environmental conflicts, which have doubled since last year. About sixty mining-related conflicts now exist across Peru.
On a more hopeful note, Garcia adds that groups have been strengthened by the results of the vote and are “demanding respect for their decision in a peaceful manner.” Over the past year, they have also been working on their own processes of participatory development planning.
But, he assesses, they pose a great risk to the Peruvian government and its model of development, possibly beyond its own borders. He says that “recognition of the results,” in reference to similar votes that have taken place in Argentina and Guatemala, “would lead to the possibility of more votes. Not just in Peru, but in all of Latin America.”
Clarification: The Ombudsman's Office did not actually say that the Rio Blanco Project is "illegal." Rather, they said that MEM had not ensured that legal process was followed in establishing the project, and that it endorsed the evaluacion biental when, had due diligence been exercised, it should not have been approved.
Jennifer Moore is an independent Canadian journalist living in Ecuador.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
11:36 AM
0
comments
Labels: Initiative and Referendum, LATIN AMERICA, PERU, Plebiscite
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
VIETNAM: Comités Populaires
17/09/2008
S'exprimant lors d'une interview accordée à l'Agence Vietnamienne d'Information (AVI) sur le projet d'élection directe du président du comité populaire communal, qui sera expérimenté dans 500 communes du pays, Uông Chu Luu, vice-président de l'Assemblée nationale (AN), l'a qualifié de "nouvelle réforme" du système électoral national.
>> Le cumul de fonctions à l’essai à Thanh Hoa
>> Un grand projet de réforme administrative
Pourquoi cette modalité d'élection n'a pas été envisagées lors de l'élaboration de la Loi sur l'organisation du conseil et du comité populaires ?
Parce qu'il s'agit d'une nouvelle réforme qui, jusqu'à présent, n'était pas envisageable. Précisément, ce genre de scrutin n'a été discuté par les organismes compétents qu'à partir du moment où la pratique de la démocratie représentative s'est approfondie, tous les problèmes étant réglés par la collectivité. De plus, maintenant que la réforme administrative s'accélère, la position, le rôle et les responsabilités du président du comité populaire seront renforcés. C'est pourquoi leur élection directe peut être expérimentée maintenant.
Est-ce que cette nouvelle modalité du pouvoir administratif, dont l'élaboration incombe au ministère de l'Intérieur, sera meilleure ?
Je pense que cette politique est parfaitement raisonnable et adaptée. Car la réforme dans l'organisation du conseil et du comité populaires ainsi que les principes de démocratie directe et représentative ont souvent été au coeur de nombreuses séances de travail de l'AN comme des plénums du Parti. Désormais, il est temps de mettre en œuvre les nouvelles modalités et plus tard, elles seront évaluées en termes d'efficacité, de souplesse et de praticabilité. Si ce projet porte ses fruits, leur principe sera généralisé par une modification de la loi en la matière.
Il y a toujours, de nos jours, des grandes lignées dans les communes et quartiers. Au cas où le président ne représente qu'une lignée, n'y a-t-il pas un danger pour l'intérêt public et la solidarité au sein de la commune ?
Cela a été l'une des préoccupations majeures pour ce projet et c'est d'ailleurs la raison du caractère expérimental de cette réforme, tout particulièrement pour ces localités où la majorité des citoyens appartiennent à une ou 2 lignées. Ceci dit, en tout état de cause, il va de soi qu'en cas de "vote partisan" dans ces dernières, il s'agira d'un manque de respect de l'intérêt général qui tournera rapidement à leur désavantage.
Selon vous, qu'est ce qu'on doit faire pour que ce projet soit efficient, en évitant le piège d'élections simplement formelles ?
De telles élections directes permettront à la population de faire valoir leur libre volonté. Une fois correctement informée des conditions sine qua non pour une candidature et l'exercice de ces fonctions, la population choisira son représentant en pleine connaissance de cause afin qu'il assume la direction et la gestion de leur commune.
Actuellement, le conseil populaire ratifie les actes du comité populaire. Avec ce projet qui implique la suppression expérimentale des conseils populaires de niveau de district et d'arrondissement, qui sera chargé de ce travail ?Ce problème est à l'étude. Pour les districts et arrondissements où cette suppression interviendra, ce travail sera exercé par le conseil populaire du ressort supérieur ou par le président du comité populaire. Ce point sera bien sûr examiné de manière approfondie.
D'après vous, le nouveau président du comité populaire communal peut-il ne pas être membre du PC vietnamien (PCV) ? Quelle est l'influence sur le rôle de direction de l’organisation du Parti de la commune en cas que le président ne soit pas membre du Parti ?
Le fait que le président du comité populaire communal est membre du PCV ou non est stipulé dans l’acte législatif. Ceux qui sont aux postes essentiels sont généralement membres de l'organisation communale du Parti ou du comité permanent de celle-ci. Quoi qu'il en soit, ils devront saisir parfaitement l'ensemble des politiques et orientations à mettre en œuvre et les appliquer dans leur localité.
Lê Hà/CVN
(17/09/2008)
* Nguyên Dinh Lôc, ex-ministre de la Justice
Nous devons faire confiance à la population. Elle est capable de choisir avec clairvoyance son représentant. La commune est la première unité administrative, celle de base. Son dirigeant est bien compris de ses habitants et son intérêt est directement relié à celui de la population. Ils sauront choisir et élire la personne digne de ces fonctions. De telles élections n'ont rien d'étrange ! De plus, au cours de ces plus de 20 ans de Renouveau, le niveau d'instruction de la population ainsi que ses connaissances de la vie sociale et politique se sont sensiblement améliorées. En ce qui me concerne, cette modalité d'élection aurait dû être appliquée depuis longtemps. En outre, le président du comité populaire communal ne doit pas forcément être membre du PCV à son élection. Ce parce qu'il pourra adhérer au PCV par la suite, et s'il est digne de la confiance de toute la population et que son prestige grandit continuellement grâce à son esprit de rénovation ainsi que sa lutte contre les manifestations négatives.
La décision de supprimer le conseil populaire du niveau de l'arrondissement et du district a été abordée à maintes reprises, en fait à chaque fois que la modification de la Constitution a été débattue.
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
12:37 PM
0
comments
Labels: Comités Populaires, Participatory Democracy, VIETNAM
UK: Community to Imitate Brazilian Participatory Budgeting
CHAIRMAN AIMING TO FINISH PROJECT
Friday, September 26, 2008, 18:33
Source: http://www.thisisplymouth.co.uk/news/CHAIRMAN-AIMING-FINISH-PROJECT/article-357191-detail/article.html
VOTERS have returned Devonport Regeneration Community Partnership chairman Marc Gardiner to the organisation's board – where he will be joined by a new face.
And newcomer Tony Burton has already set targets: jobs and trees.
"I'm very flattered the people of Devonport have voted me into a position of trust, and I hope not to fail them," he said.
"My main interest is jobs. Given the economic downturn I'd like to see a lot of effort put into providing employment."
And trees?
More trees," he said. "For the aesthetics of Devonport. Years ago there were areas of Victorian houses with trees. They look nice and provide more oxygen."
Mr Burton lived in Devonport 18 years ago, but left for Beacon Park after suffering daily abuse and intimidation.
But now he's back and said Devonport has 'completely changed'.
"It's a wonderful, caring community," he said. "And I plan to keep it that way."
Mr Burton, who works in plumbing and home improvements, was voted in alongside Mr Gardiner, a board member since 2002, and Roger Wills and Anne Freeman, both re-elected.
Garry Edwards and Agnes Reynolds failed to be elected.
The election was the last for resident board members before the New Deal for Communities organisation, set up with £48.73million of public cash to regenerate the area, is wound up in 2011 at the end of its 10-year lifespan.
If any board vacancies occur from now on they will be filled with appointees.
Mr Gardiner said the board had the important job of seeing the project through to 'a satisfactory conclusion' and establishing a successor organisation.
And he also wants to use the final years to 'empower' locals to use their 'voice' en masse.
He said this could be done via 'participatory budgeting' an idea imported from Brazil.
"It's an example of direct democracy," he said.
Participatory budgeting would mean setting aside a fraction of the NDC's cash, allowing people to bid for it and present ideas, and then letting the populace to decide which to run with.
"I'd like to see DRC Partnership pilot that for the city," he said.
Miss Freeman was delighted to have the opportunity to see the regeneration project through, and wants to concentrate on promoting education and training.
She stressed: "It's not just about bricks and mortar, you have to regenerate the people and provide opportunities for them."
And Mr Wills said: "Education was my banner the first time I stood, and I stick by that."
He has lived in Devonport since 1976 and remembers times when it was like 'Beirut' – but not now.
"The regeneration that's going on is wonderful," he said.
The election's 17.91 per cent turn-out was down on the 25.73 per cent of eligible Devonport residents who voted last year and the 25.84 in 2005.
But spokeswoman Lynda Harris said the DRC Partnership was 'delighted' with the figure.
"Some NDCs have stopped elections," she said. "The fact that people are still turning out and wanting to vote says a lot."
Posted by
Democracy By The People
at
12:19 PM
1 comments
Labels: Direct Democracy, EUROPE, Participatory Budgeting, UNITED KINGDOM